2

There are two mentions of Jonah prophesying in the Bible, once in 2 Kings and once in Jonah. Were those two seperate prophecies for two seperate kings?

I am curious if both passages refer too the same prophecy or if there were two seperate prophecies which did not come to pass. I have always been told that Jonah did not want to go to Nineveh because he despised Nineveh and wanted to see it destroyed. I am wondering if it could be accurate to theorize that part of the reason Jonah fled is because his pride was hurt as a result of unfulfilled prophesy and he did not want to be proven wrong again? Jonah 4:2

3 Answers 3

3

Jonah was a true prophet of God. Both his prophecies came to pass. He did want to see Nineveh destroyed. And when he said: ”yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown (”nehpaket”)”, the prophecy was fulfilled. But not the way he hoped it would.

2015. haphak הָפַךְ - to turn, overturn

He hoped that Nineveh would be destroyed, but instead it flipped 180 degrees and repented.

3

The brief mention of Jonah in 2 Kings 14:25 states that a prophecy he uttered did come to pass. We are not told what that prophecy was, only that it had to do with the extent of Israel's boundaries. It helps date Jonah's ministry.

The prophecy we are given details about has to do with God telling Jonah to go to the great city of Nineveh "and preach against it" (1:4) due to its great wickedness. We know that Jonah disobeyed at first, but then did do as God commanded. He preached that Nineveh would be overturned in forty days. However, that was a provisional warning, dependent on whether the people would repent or not.

The brevity of Jonah's preaching - confined to repeating merely eight words - belies the other bit of information provided, namely, that he was preaching there for three days. We are told what he said on the first day. That is all (3:4). Here is a commentary on that:

"There is no mention made of the second or third day, presumably because of the immediacy of the response. He began his first day's activities, and - then we are not told precisely how far into the first day, but the implication is not too far - he proclaimed, 'Forty more days and Nineveh will be overturned.'

"...Is this all that he said? It seems unlikely. The terse style of the narrative has demonstrably led to condensation in many places (1:10; 4:2), and that seems probable here also. Certainly the knowledge the king shows of the grounds of divine condemnation in 3:8 suggests that Jonah clearly told them why this judgment was impending.

Did Jonah tell them about his own experience? From the book of Jonah itself there is nothing to prove this. In the N.T., however, Jesus clearly says, 'This is a wicked generation. It asks for a miraculous sign, but none will be given it except the sign of Jonah. For as Jonah was a sign to the Ninevites, so also will the Son of Man be to this generation.' (Luke 11:29-30)...

It is thus the case that when Jonah preached in Nineveh, we are not to think of him as only uttering the words, 'Forty more days, and Nineveh will be overturned.' The main theme of his message was God's impending judgment on sin, so as to stir up the Ninevites to the gravity of their situation.... In this way we can see that the message Jonah eventually brought to the Nineveh went further than that announced in 1:2. Originally the emphasis had been on divine displeasure with the conduct of the Ninevites. Now it became one of imminent punishment, but with the prophet himself as a living example of God's willingness and power to save." (Jonah pp 41-42, John L. Mackay, Christian Focus, 1998)

The judgment of God would certainly have been carried out IF the king and the citizens had not repented. Just because God showed mercy when they heeded his warning is no basis for saying Jonah's prophecy failed; that it did not come to pass. We are not told all the words of the message proclaimed by Jonah. If that message included mention of the possibility of averting disaster should they repent, then the entirety of the message would mean that what Jonah preached was the truth.

It is significant that Jesus stated God looking with favour on the repentant Ninevites. Jesus used their repentance to warn the people of his day: "The men of Nineveh will stand up at the judgment with this generation and condemn it; for they repented at the preaching of Jonah, and now one greater than Jonah is here" (Matthew 12:41; Luke 11:32). That is why I would argue that both of Jonah's prophecies came to pass.

Footnote: This link might be helpful for further information on the matter of Jonah and the ancient city of Nineveh - https://armstronginstitute.org/639-is-the-book-of-jonah-entirely-ahistorical

0

It is a very valid question.

Jonah's prophecy regarding Ninevah did not come to pass.

It is a very old interpretation of the book of Jonah that he did not want to be made to appear as a false prophet, and that is why he was angry with God for potentially undermining his standing in Israel as a prophet.

It is commonly believed Jonah preached that the Ninevites should repent, but this is not what scriptures reveals: he simply said that in 40 days the city would be destroyed. The Ninevites reasoned it would do no harm to repent; maybe God would change his mind and relent. Furthermore, it is clear from what our Lord Jesus says that the Ninevites knew that God forgave Jonah himself at the last hour when he repented in the belly of the fish (Matthew 12:38-41).

So they repented and God relented, making Jonah look like a false prophet.

But we know virtually nothing about Jonah except what is in his book and 2 Kings. So its impossible to say if he had been put in a similar position before. Clearly the Lord did not put him in a similar predicament in 2 Kings 14:25 because we are clearly told his prophecy came true.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .