0

I have some but not much idea about the differences between Mainline and Evangelical.

I looked up the two words in dictionary, but I am wondering what relations are between their general non-religious meanings to their religious usages?

For example, I can't tell how the meanings in https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mainline relate to its religious usage.

Thanks.

3

ORGANIZATIONALLY (non-religious sense), both Mainline and Evangelical terms refer to 2 different ways that Protestant churches are governed in North America. Mainline churches are part of a hierarchy (sometimes called a denomination) but Evangelical churches are usually independent from one another so frequently called non-denominational. But for accountability, some evangelical churches belong to one or more fellowship / association such as the Southern Baptist Convention. Note that the term "denomination" is rather loosely applied, so a "non-denominational" association like Southern Baptist Convention is sometimes called a denomination.

Note that although the term "Mainline" appeared later (1920s) than the term "Evangelical" (1812), the older Mainline churches have existed much earlier. Presbyterian Church USA, for example, traced their origin to early 1700s when 7 Presbyterian ministers formed the first presbytery in 1706.

When it comes to RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, both mainline and evangelical churches are also Protestant in their theologies, derived ultimately from the teaching of the original reformers Martin Luther and Calvin (Reformed) or the later John Wesley (for Methodists). But the Evangelical brand of theology, which started in the early 18th century, has certain distinctive characteristics: a blend of Puritanism, Pietism, and Presbyterianism, stressing the conversion and experiential aspects rather than the membership and liturgical aspects of being a Christian. They also have the tendency to form revivals such as the Great Awakening. See wikipedia for more history.

But in the past 200 years or so, mainline Protestant theologies in North America grew more modernist / liberal (see a comparison in this 2004 PBS Frontline article). As the conservative factions within mainline churches began to split especially in the latter half of the 20th century, they formed their own churches which are mainline in government, but evangelical in teaching, such as the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.

As a result the term "Evangelical" now is more associated with a distinctiveness in religious beliefs rather than in the non-religious sense because some mainline churches have adopted "evangelical" in their name. For the same reason, evangelical churches now are no longer uniformly Reformed in their beliefs because we now have evangelical churches that trace their origin to Lutheran, Methodist, and Anglican, theologies as well.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thanks. Do words Presbyterian, Reformed and Calvinism mean the same? I guess yes from your reply and en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestantism_in_the_United_States – Tim May 29 at 21:41
  • Presbyterian usually refers to church government type (has presbytery, synods, etc.), while Reformed (and its very close synonym Calvinism, since it's based on the teachings of John Calvin) refers to a type of Protestant theology. A typical evangelical church can teach Reformed theology but the church government is NOT Presbyterian. – GratefulDisciple May 29 at 21:54
  • "Evangelical" doesn't imply independence or non-denominationalism, and there are evangelical Lutherans, Anglicans, Presbyterians, Baptists, Methodists etc. I don't think the SBC should really be described as non-denominational either, they're one of the biggest denominations ever, with lots of denominational sub-institutions! – curiousdannii May 30 at 1:34
1

In Christian usage the word 'mainline' (or "mainstream') means exactly what the dictionary says. It means one of the large, organized denominations. It is often modified, so "mainline Protestant" would mean one of the large organized Protestant denominations. You might talk about "mainline Latter-day Saints" to mean the main body of LDS and exclude fringe groups related to them.

The term "Evangelical" was originally a Christian term, and only developed a secular usage by derivation from the Christian term. In other words you might refer to an "Evangelical vegetarian" (meaning a vegetarian who tries to convert others to the vegetarian cause) but it makes sense only if people are familiar with the Christian meaning.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.