In the Bible, in several passages, the Apostles narrate events that they where not participating in. For example, the story of the woman at the Well and the conversation between Jesus and Pilate.

The Apostles were not present during these interactions, how did they know about them? How did they know they happened in the first place?

In the case of Pilate, Jesus died after that, so I think he didn't have the opportunity to tell the Apostles what had happened, even after his resurrection!

  • Surely either Jesus or the woman of Samaria spoke of their conversation. John writes of a disciple (almost certainly himself) who knew the High Priest (John 18:15) and was admitted to the palace at the time of Jesus' interrogation. Jesus rose from the dead and spoke a great deal with his disciples before his ascension. I really don't see a problem, myself. – Nigel J Mar 16 at 16:01

We know that Jesus said and worked many more miracles than are simply mentioned in the Gospels.

St. John’s last words of his Gospel admits as much.

25 Now qthere are also many other things that Jesus did. Were every one of them to be written, I suppose that rthe world itself could not contain the books that would be written. - John 21:25

Just because the Gospels do not reveal everything or even how the Apostles became in possession of the events and conversations Our Lord had, when none of the Apostles where present is not hard to imagine.

There are basically just a few ways that the Apostles acquired this knowledge.

Either Our Lord revealed this to them himself and it is not mentioned in Scriptures as such. Or, the possibility that a third party revealed such information to the Apostles.

The Samaritan woman at the well was very talkative as the Gospels point out. She told everyone about Jesus. Perhaps she herself or one of the inhabitants from Sychar told the Apostles what happened. Again perhaps Our Lord told them after his resurrection! We may truly never know, while on earth, but then that is food for contemplation.

39 Many Samaritans from that town believed in him because of the woman's testimony, “He told me all that I ever did.” 40 So when the Samaritans came to him, they asked him to stay with them, and he stayed there two days. 41 And many more believed because of his word. 42 They said to the woman, “It is no longer because of what you said that we believe, for we have heard for ourselves, and we know that this is indeed the Savior of the world.” - John 4:38-42

As for Pilate’s conversation with Christ, it was not private. There were eyewitnesses! Did one of these tell the apostles what transpired between them or did Jesus mention it after his resurrection we may never know.

There is a tradition within some Christian denominations that Pilate’s wife became a believer and as such could have talked about it to Jesus’ Disciples!

Pontius Pilate's wife is the unnamed spouse of Pontius Pilate, who appears only once in the Gospel of Matthew, where she intercedes with Pilate on Jesus' behalf. It is uncertain whether Pilate was actually married, although it is likely. In later tradition, she becomes known as Procula (Latin: Procula) or Procla (Ancient Greek: Πρόκλα) and plays a role in various New Testament Apocrypha. At a later date, she acquires the name Claudia Procula in Western tradition, as well as other names and variants of these names. She is venerated as a saint by the Orthodox Church, the Coptic Church, and the Ethiopian Church. She has also frequently been featured in literature and film.

There are so many mysteries within the Scriptures and the Gospels in particular, that we have an endless source of contemplation and admiration as to try to even remotely understand how the Apostles know so much!

In the end, the Evangelists were convinced that this information would be useful for our edification and contemplation.

Ut in omnibus glorificetur Deus!

| improve this answer | |

Ken Graham's answer handles one side of your question nicely, but he takes up the problem of "How" the Gospel writers got the information. But you asked, "Why?"

If you were the woman at the well, even as sinful as you were, would you approach the well if thirteen strange men were hanging out there? No. They might attack you. Only because Jesus was alone did she gather the courage to approach.

If you were Nicodemus, afraid of losing your position in the Sanhedrin or even being arrested just for being seen with Jesus, would you show up at a time when there might be many witnesses?

If you were one of Pilate's guards, officials, or even wife, would you want Luke (who interviewed many witnesses) or another Gospel writer to put your name in a document and list you as a source, an action that might get you killed?

With this in mind, since I myself have carefully investigated everything from the beginning, I too decided to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus (Luke 1:3)

Luke compassionately did not list his sources, like a good journalist.

| improve this answer | |

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.