4

Muhammad claimed to be God's Prophet, even God's Last Prophet. As such his life should measure up as a godly life. Using only the most approved Muslim sources, the Qur'an, and the most highly regarded Hadith i.e. the Sahih Bukhari, the Sahih Muslim and Sunan Abu Daud, and Guillaume's "Life of Muhammed" how does Muhammad's life compare with the standards of the Bible? Or how does his life compare with the life of our Lord Jesus? Is there anything to cause us to doubt his status as a prophet?

I am not really interested in his teachings. I appreciate that is very important, but other questions can address that. I just want to have answers about his behaviour.

|improve this question
  • 3
    As written, this question is definitely close-worthy because answers must make a value judgment regarding what the Bible teaches. However, recasting it somewhat – and adjusting answers accordingly – as something like "On what basis do Evangelical [or Catholic, or Mormon, etc.] apologists argue that Muhammad committed sin?" would result in much more focused answers and less debate. – Nathaniel is protesting Jul 9 '19 at 19:59
  • @Nathaniel - Thanks. But if I posted a question such as "On what basis do evangelicals... etc", how would it not get deleted if I posted more or less the same answer? – Andrew Shanks Jul 9 '19 at 20:02
  • @Nathaniel - Also, I am being accused of hate-speech (!), using biased sources, making offensive statements. What I am really doing is putting statements together which are all usually swept under the carpet, statements from the Qur'an itself and statements which are written by Muslims, in the most highly regarded sources of hadith that exist in the Muslim world. This is surely of value, when Islam claims to supercede Christianity, and it is claimed the Qur'an trumps the Bible. – Andrew Shanks Jul 9 '19 at 20:10
  • 2
    The beauty of answering "here's what evangelical apologist A says and here's how evangelical organization B argues" is that you are describing the viewpoint of a Christian group/tradition. It may happen to correspond with your own view, but that's not the focus, and any comments challenging the views you present can be swiftly rebutted by saying "are you saying that I have failed to accurately capture the views of evangelical apologist A?" – Nathaniel is protesting Jul 9 '19 at 20:57
  • Another way to look at this – your answer seems to be an attempt to demonstrate that Islam believes certain things, and this naturally raises the hackles of people who disagree with you. But if we remember that this site is meant to be used as a way to share what Christian traditions believe, then answers can share how Christian traditions deal with certain aspects of other religions. – Nathaniel is protesting Jul 9 '19 at 21:01