5

I would like to know if the Book of Enoch was dated around 3000 BC and what language did he speak and is there any carbon dating that was use on any book found? And where are the oldest Scripture of his writings kept?

  • Welcome to the site. This is a good question, except that no reliable answer can be given. The "book of Enoch" that we have would be a much later copy and probably in Hebrew, although there may be early Greek translations. I hope someone can give you a partial answer or point you to helpful related questions. I hope you stick around. You may wish to take the tour and read the help center if you have not. – b and d restore Monica Mar 24 at 19:20
  • 1
    I think the main question that would need to be addressed is why did Moses (and subsequent Jewish authorities ) include the book of Job in scripture but not the so-called book of Enoch. – Nigel J Mar 24 at 20:06
  • Wikipedia says 300 BC not 3000 BC. – George White Mar 24 at 21:19
  • 2
    We can't answer this objectively. Some Christians think the "Book of Enoch" is an authentic writing from Enoch, but most do not. – curiousdannii Mar 25 at 8:18
  • @GeorgeWhite that looks like the start of an answer. – KorvinStarmast Mar 25 at 13:22
11

Just because it's called the Book of Enoch doesn't mean it's written by him. It's considered one of Pseudopigraphical book, literally "false attribution" (See: Pseudepigrapha (Wikipedia).

The subsequent description was taken from the IVP Dictionary of New Testament Background, Entry: Enoch, Books Of.

1 Enoch consists of 5 distinct compositions:

  1. Book of the Watchers (Chapter 1-36) : oldest Aramaic fragment is Dead Sea Scrolls dated first half of the 2nd century BC. Scholars believe the book took shape in the 3rd or early 2nd century BC.

  2. The Similitudes (Chapter 37-71) : no fragments have been found in the Dead Sea Scrolls. Some scholars suggested it was a late 3rd century AD Christian composition, but some dated it to the early 1st century AD prior to 70 AD.

  3. The Astronomical Book (Chapters 72-82) : oldest Aramaic fragment have been dated to the 3rd century BC.

  4. The Book of Dreams (Chapters 83-90) : scholars believe it was written at the time of the Maccabean revolt (167 BC)

  5. The Epistle of Enoch (Chapters 91-105): scholars have dated it to the early 1st century BC; others dated it to the early 2nd century BC

Almost all of the Dead Sea Scrolls collection is housed in the Shrine of the Book (part of the Israel Museum) in Jerusalem: Dead Sea Scrolls. See the wikipedia article about Radiocarbon and Paleographic dating.

3

What was the language that Enoch spoke and did the Book of Enoch get written 3000 years BC and is there any proof or carbon dating of that?

Let us start with what language Enoch possible spoke.

There is no firm proof of what language Enoch actually spoke. But several hypotheses do exist.

One possible hypothesis comes from what else Wikipedia:

The Adamic language is, according to Jewish tradition (as recorded in the midrashim) and some Christians, the language spoken by Adam (and possibly Eve) in the Garden of Eden. It is variously interpreted as either the language used by God to address Adam (the divine language), or the language invented by Adam with which he named all things (including Eve), as in the second Genesis creation myth (Genesis 2:19).

In the Middle Ages, various Jewish commentators held that Adam spoke Hebrew, a view also addressed in various ways by the late medieval Christian writer Dante Alighieri. In the early modern period, some authors continued to discuss the possibility of an Adamic language, some continuing to hold to the idea that it was Hebrew, while others such as John Locke were more skeptical. More recently, a variety of Mormon authors have expressed various opinions about the nature of the Adamic language. - Adamic language

The Book of Enoch is regarded as canonical by the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church and Eritrean Orthodox Tewahedo Church. Thus the traditional Ethiopian belief is that Enoch spoke the Ge'ez language.

It is wholly extant only in the Ge'ez language, with Aramaic fragments from the Dead Sea Scrolls and a few Greek and Latin fragments. For this and other reasons, the traditional Ethiopian belief is that the original language of the work was Ge'ez, whereas modern scholars argue that it was first written in either Aramaic or Hebrew; Ephraim Isaac suggests that the Book of Enoch, like the Book of Daniel, was composed partially in Aramaic and partially in Hebrew.[5]:6 No Hebrew version is known to have survived. It is asserted in the book itself that its author was Enoch, before the Biblical Flood. - Book of Enoch (Wikipedia)

It seems almost everyone had a view on this subject:

The nature of that original language remains controversial, interpretations showing many nationalist flavours:

•Traditional Jewish exegesis such as Midrash (Genesis Rabbah 38) says that Adam spoke Old Hebrew or rather its linguistic ancestor Proto-Canaanite, because the names he gives Eve – “Isha” (Book of Genesis 2:23) and “Chava” (Genesis 3:20) – only make sense in Hebrew.

•Traditional Christians based on Genesis 10:5 have assumed that the Japhetite, or Indo-European, languages are rather the direct descendants of the Adamic language, having separated before the confusion of tongues, by which also Hebrew was affected.

1.Early Christian fathers claimed that Adam spoke Latin to explain why God would make it the liturgical language of his Church, although “Latin” here would be a loose way of referring to its ancestor, Proto-Italic or older Europe’s Indo-European.

2.Modern traditional Catholics follow Anne Catherine Emmerick’s revelations (1790), which stated that the most direct descendants of the Adamic language were Bactrian, Zend and Indian languages (i.e., the Indo-Iranian languages), associating the Adamic language with the then-recent concept of the “common source” of these tongues, now known as Proto-Indo-European:

This language was the pure Hebrew, or Chaldaic. The first tongue, the mother tongue, spoken by Adam, Shem, and Noah, was different, and it is now extant only in isolated dialects. Its first pure offshoots are the Zend, the sacred tongue of India, and the language of the Bactrians. In those languages, words may be found exactly similar to the Low German of my native place.

From Adamic or the language of the Garden of Eden until the Tower of Babel: the confusion of tongues and the earliest dialects attested

Now for something about the Book of Enoch itself:

The Book of Enoch (also 1 Enoch; Ge'ez: መጽሐፈ ሄኖክ maṣḥafa hēnok) is an ancient Jewish religious work, ascribed by tradition to Enoch, the great-grandfather of Noah. Enoch warrants special attention for the unique material it holds, such as the origins of supernatural demons and giants, why some angels fell from heaven, details explaining why the Great Flood was morally necessary, and prophetic exposition of the thousand-year reign of the Messiah.

The older sections (mainly in the Book of the Watchers) of the text are estimated to date from about 300 BCE, and the latest part (Book of Parables) probably to the 1st century BCE. - Book of Enoch (Wikipedia)

Thus we see that oldest portion of the Book of Enoch I placed at about 300 BCE and not 3,000 BCE as is mentioned in the question. That simply does not mean that older texts at one time did exist or that Enoch is not the author. It is the oldest copy we have. It seems history may have passed into legend and we may never know the truth.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.