4

This is probably not a surprised to scripture veterans, but noticed that Mark 1:2-3 is a quotation from two separate sources, Isaiah and Malachi, but it is ascribed only to Isaiah by the author of Mark. That leads the question above.

  • 1
    Mark says that the quotations come from 'as it is written in the prophets' [KJV] ως γεγραπται εν τοις προφηταις [Stephens 1550]. Why do you say the writer only attributes Isaiah ? – Nigel J Aug 29 '18 at 20:47
  • @NigelJ The NASB says "As it is written in Isaiah the prophet..." (Mark 1:2). It makes no mention of Malachi or any prophet other than Isaiah. – Calicoder Aug 30 '18 at 19:08
  • 1
    Stephens, Elzevir, Beza and Scrivener all agree : ως γεγραπται εν τοις προφηταις, as it is written in the prophets. – Nigel J Aug 31 '18 at 0:08
1

Rick Watts, a New Testament Professor at Regent College, wrote this article in response to a reader's question raising the same issue. It turns out the discrepancy was already noted as far back as in the 4th century A.D. by St. Jerome, the famous Latin Vulgate translator!

It looks like the earliest manuscripts left "in Isaiah" intact while later manuscripts made the adjustment, thinking that Mark made a mistake, as St. Jerome observed "O Apostle Peter, your son Mark, not in the flesh but in the Spirit, has made a mistake." So those later manuscripts inappropriately tampered with the text and changed it to "in the prophets". It looks like KJV used a later manuscript while modern translations like NASB and ESV used an earlier manuscript.

Dr. Watts wrote that there was a pattern in the Gospel of Mark, when bringing together separate texts to form a composite citation that "mutually inform and interpret one another" (in this case Isaiah 40:3 and Malachi 3:1). Mark, following common 1st century practice, would cite only the most important author that provides the "primary interpretative horizon", which in this case is Isaiah.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.