4

Fernando Álvarez de Toledo, 3rd Duke of Alba was sent by Philip II of Spain to Belgium where he waged war against the protestants in the area.

As a bit of history, Belgium in the 16th Century started out as part of the "Seventeen Provinces" within the Burgundian Netherlands. Belgium was formed after the Eighty Years' War (1568–1648)

On February 16, 1568, the entire population of the Netherlands—three million—was condemned to death as heretics, apart from a few named exceptions:

Philip next submitted a "Memorial and Representation" of the state of the Low Countries to the Spanish Inquisition craving the judgment of the Fathers upon it. After deliberating, the inquisitors pronounced their decision on the 16th of February, 1568. It was to the effect that, "with the exception of a select list of names which had been handed to them, all the inhabitants of the Netherlands were heretics or abettors of heresy, and so had been guilty of the crime of high treason." On the 26th of the same month, Philip confirmed this sentence by a proclamation, in which he commanded the decree to be carried into immediate execution, without favour or respect of persons. The King of Spain actually passed sentence of death upon a whole nation. We behold him erecting a common scaffold for its execution, and digging one vast grave for all the men, and women, and children of the Low Countries. "Since the beginning of the world," says Brandt, "men have not seen or heard any parallel to this horrible sentence. (Wylie, History of Protestantism, vol. II, p. 70.)

Would the sending of the 3rd Duke of Alba to Belgium and his following actions be considered a Catholic Crusade?

  • This example of 'ethnic cleansing' (or, at least, intention thereof) has profound implications. If it was justified then, is it justified now ? – Nigel J Aug 26 '18 at 9:55
  • @NigelJ - The death penalty was prescribed in the past for heresy towards certain Christian faiths. Whether it is considered to be justified now is for another question. – Chris Rogers Aug 26 '18 at 10:00
4

Professor Petrus Johannes Blok was Professor of Dutch History at Leiden University, the Netherlands oldest university, in the late 19th and early 20th century. In 1907 he identified that the decree sentencing almost all Netherlands inhabitants to death, and depriving them of their property, said to have been promulgated in Spain in 1568, was actually a forgery dating from some time in the 1570s. In a sense then, it was, according to the Professor, fake news, but from the 16th century; and generally accepted by historians until the 20th.

See page 42-43 of "Britain and the Netherlands Volume 5" by Bromley and Kossmann .

The Netherlands Inquisition had been running for several decades already and, as Phillip II himself observed, was less merciful than the Spanish. At one time heretics who refused to repent could be burned. If a man or boy repented he could be beheaded, but if a woman or girl repented she could be buried alive.

This article, on the website of St Andrew's University, the oldest in Scotland, quotes estimates of 50,000 to 100,00 deaths. After the Duke of Albi arrived many more thousands of deaths were inflicted, it says.

This was the same Duke of Albi who in 1556 had besieged Rome and threatened to sack the city if the then pope did not accept his terms.

However no attempt was made to exterminate almost all the inhabitants of the Netherlands indiscriminately. The decree, even if it had existed, was not acted upon. That the Duke of Alba did lead a force to the Netherlands and that much persecution followed is true.

The historical details are somewhat disputed and perhaps the History site might provide some answers as to roughly how many perished, and how many suffered other punishment or went into exile.

If, in fact, the Pope had approved a campaign to kill all 3,00,000, many of whom were Catholic anyway, and had called on all Catholics to support it, then that would have been a most extraordinary thing. We can only speculate whether it might have been called a crusade, or what it might have been called.

Rather depressingly, perhaps, what actually happened was, in the context of sixteenth century Europe, more a case of "business as usual".

1

No, it would not be considered in any historical sense a crusade. There hadn't been a crusade (i.e. 1-7) for 300 years at that point. Catholic historians consider the fight against the Albigensians and the struggle to reclaim Andalusia "crusades" 1. But this struggle doesn't have the hallmarks of a crusade. Namely, a concerted force of Christian soldiers, knights and nobles from all of Christendom fighting against a common foe at the behest of the Pope.

The curious thing about this point of "history" is that it doesn't seem to be remembered in the same way that the massacre of the 2000 Hugenots in Paris a few years later.2

And, if this were a real inquisition, not just a Protestant revisionist historical tract - as James Wylie is famous for, it would have noted that the Inquisition didn't operate this way until an individual backslided on their repentance.3

Furthermore, unlike the Plantagenet kings of England and some of the Emperors of the Holy Roman Empire, the Spanish kings were subservient to the Pope and wouldn't have any authority the kill on person, let alone an entire country on religious grounds. If he ordered the Duke of Alba to do this thing which obviously never happened because it would have at least as much historical implications as the Holocaust and not be overshadowed (as I said above) by the very real massacre of the Hugenots. These things are recorded here, 19th century fake news, futher proof that there is nothing new under the sun.

Even furthermore, 3 years later, Phillip's own half-brother Don Juan of Austria was busy defending Christendom (probably saving the country that Phillip had apparently sentenced to death) at the Battle of Lepanto and that isn't even considered a crusade. 4

So, no I don't think anybody would call these actions a crusade.

1,2,3,4 All random facts sourced from Light to the Nations part one, The History of Christian Civilization,

  • "If he ordered the Duke of Alba to do this thing which obviously never happened" read familysearch.org/wiki/en/… – Chris Rogers Aug 27 '18 at 6:01
  • The part of this answer denouncing the historical facts as false is insulting and abusive to those who's ancestry (which I am not one of them by the way) were persecuted in Belgium. – Chris Rogers Aug 27 '18 at 6:37
  • @chris were 2 million people were executed? – Peter Turner Aug 27 '18 at 12:41
  • I don’t know the figures but many of those condemned were. The exception are those who managed to flee. There are quite a few accounts in various books. One of them was in the memoirs of Sir William Hoste who sailed with Nelson. He descended from someone who fled the persecution and there is an account of another ancestor of his who was burnt alive. Her portrait was hung in Sandringham House which now belongs to the English Royal Family. – Chris Rogers Aug 27 '18 at 15:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.