0

As a follow up to Similarities and differences between the priesthood of all believers and the LDS priesthood, I ask what are similarities and differences between the priesthood in the Catholic and LDS Church?

Some obvious similarities are the hierarchical structure, and emphasis on education. Obvious differences include the ratio of priesthood holders to non-priesthood holders, and the formality of education required.

Note: I'm just looking for an overview/summary. Every similarity and difference would obviously be too big for this site.

1

I sincerely apologize that this will (and does) read like a long comment, but the comments section is too limiting to make the point.

The odds are that the only person who could answer this question well would be an active bearer of the priesthood in one church who apostatizes from it, converts to the other and thereby becomes an active bearer of the priesthood in the other.

...and that might be a pretty small group of people. Active members of any church rarely convert to other churches.1

Let me cite a few examples of the problem.

  • (Pro-LDS) The Encyclopedia of Mormonism in the article "Catholicism and Mormonism," under the subheading "AUTHORITY," gives a bland one-paragraph statement that basically only introduces the idea of how the two organizations look at the authority held by the apostle Peter. (And, IMHO, it doesn't even do that particularly well.)

  • (Neutral) In "Mormonism: An analysis of doctrine in comparison to Catholic and other Protestant faiths"2 author Anne Latham of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology tries to describe the LDS perspective in comparison to other beliefs. The article compares very few things, and it's obvious that she either isn't LDS herself or is writing from a non-LDS perspective. For example, she explains that men receive the Melchizedek Priesthood when they become High Priests. Actually, men receive the Melchizedek Priesthood when they are first called to serve in any M.P. office, most commonly the office of Elder after they turn 18 and prepare to serve a mission.

  • (Pro-Catholic) A third example comes from Catholic.com. The article is a decidedly anti-LDS article filled with shallow statements that misrepresent the LDS faith. Which is curious, as this apparently not-affiliated-with-the-Catholic-Church ministry claims it began when "a Fundamentalist church in San Diego, California, decided to leaflet the cars at a local parish during Mass. The fliers attacked the Eucharist and were riddled with misinformation." (source).

My point is, neither organization really understands the other.3 I would hope there are scholars in each that could answer this question with the objectivity it needs, but if there are, they're not publishing on the Internet in a way that's easy to find.

Recommendation

Therefore, I recommend this question be deleted. Instead, I recommend you ask something like: "From the perspective of [sect], how is its priesthood or ecclesiastical authority derived, organized and used?" This will get you detailed answers about specific priesthood practices that can thereafter be compared. And I suspect the group of people who can answer said question(s) increases thousands fold.


1This is perhaps an egregious blanket statement. Let's put it another way, "people who are so active in their church that they participate in leadership and/or ministerial roles rarely convert to other churches." And whey they do, it's usually after a crisis of faith that led them to wonder why on earth they're attending the church they do.

2Frankly, the title of this article and its hosting school should have foreshadowed its quality. I'm hoping the author left the word "other" in as a typographic mistake and didn't really mean to imply that the Catholic Church was Protestant. Or, perhaps, she mistakenly left the word "Protestant" in and meant Catholicism and other churches? And why am I reading a religious article from an institute of technology? Anyway...

3Which isn't surprising. In fact, speaking about each organization's membership generally, it's probably fostered and desirable. But, perhaps on a more positive note, speaking from my own perspective as an active LDS member, my religion is my life. There isn't a whole lot of time available to really study other religions. That's why sites like this are so valuable.

  • I mean like structurally. It's obviously a bit fit for this site to ask what each is like to be a part of. – PyRulez Mar 25 '18 at 19:09
  • See the linked question for the type of answer I was looking for. – PyRulez Mar 25 '18 at 20:07
  • Your linked question isn't asking about structural hierarchy and this question doesn't specifically ask about it, either. But knowing that's all you want, I suspect my complaint still stands. The Catholic structure of priesthood is so different compared to the LDS structure that I can honestly say there are no similarities. But I'm not qualified to discuss the differences in detail. I doubt many are. That's why I recommended deleting this Q and asking new Qs the way I suggested. So that you get clear explanations from experts in each faith, and the comparison is yours to make. – JBH Mar 25 '18 at 22:33
  • Sorry, I should have been more clear. Structure isn't the only thing, but it should be only "objective" things. Since the way the two organizations work isn't a secret, all you need is a catholic and a mormon to come together and make a Venn diagram, in theory. – PyRulez Mar 25 '18 at 22:43
  • I agree, but the problem is that's two answers in a world that only wants one. Thus, my suggestion you ask two questions. – JBH Mar 25 '18 at 22:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.