While reading J. V. Fesko's The Theology of the Westminster Standards, I found an interesting tidbit in the context of his discussion of justification in Reformed theology:

Medieval theologians such as Lombard argued that Old Testament men were justified through circumcision and women were justified by their faith and good works.

Reformed theology, of course, rejects this idea, holding that justification is by faith alone (not circumcision nor good works). But the idea that men were justified on a different basis than women is still intriguing, so I'd like to better understand the view.

What is the basis for arguing that men and women in the OT were justified through different means? More specifically, here are a few aspects of the question:

  • What is the biblical and logical basis for such a view?
  • Why would there be two means of justification, one for men and one for women?
  • Why would men not also be justified on the basis of "faith and good works"?
  • Would faith thus not be required for men to be justified?

I'd like to restrict the question to the views of Lombard and other scholastics – here I'm not looking for post-Reformation versions of this view.

  • I’ve sent a request through my local library to the University of Michigan for their copy of Lombard’s Sentences. I’ll see if I can find what Lombard actually said. – Zenon Oct 22 '17 at 0:09
  • I find this topic interesting, but am unqualified to offer a "Pre-Reformation" viewpoint or one that includes the view of Lombard. Instead, I could offer the Biblical and logical basis for such a view and answers to most if not all of the sub-bullets. As I wrote, this would have nothing to do with Lombard or his viewpoints and everything to do with putting myself into the mindset of someone who would attempt to argue this things solely from a Scriptural and logical standpoint. – user31124 Dec 3 '17 at 8:00
  • An English translation, done in the 1980s, seems to be available online at franciscan-archive.org/lombardus/I-Sent.html . – bit chaser Nov 3 '18 at 13:03

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.