My religion Hinduism allows me to follow any God I like. But based on my research so far Christianity would not allow its followers to follow other religions. Is it true? If it is true is Christianity liberal to other religions? Are there any Christian denominations that would allow me to believe in other religions as well.

A girl I like wants me to be a Christian. For me personally love between humans is equally important and divine as love between human and God. I still can convert to Christianity if she really wants me to. But for that I have to completely stop believing in Hinduism. So as a Hindu I can be a Christian, but as a Christian I cannot be a Hindu. Is it a good philosophy for the society in this age of modern and globalized world?

  • 1
    A core tenant of Christianity is that there is only one God. As such, believing in any other god(s) is clearly un-Christian by very definition. Beyond that, you've asked a very broad question ("Is it a good philosophy for the society in this age of modern and globalized world?" -- this is clearly an opinion-based question we cannot answer here) – Flimzy May 21 '16 at 14:39
  • The idea Thomas Aquinas gave on how God Himself could enter his creation very interesting given your Hindu background. He explained by analogy: God created the world using His Mind, and entered his creation much like you and I enter our own dreams, which are products of our own minds. The way God entered human history in the person of Christ is LIKE that.This analogy may have some resonance with you. Supplementing rhetorician's answer; Christians are free to believe there is some truth in all Religions, but that Christianity possesses the entirety of Truth- and other religions only some. – shiningcartoonist May 23 '16 at 19:21
  • If you did convert to Christianity seriously, you are still free to believe whatever Hinduism teaches that is also compatible with Christianity; but favoring Christianity. Any morality, ethics or practices which do not contradict Christ's message you can continue believing. So you do not have to completely reject your culture. Because Christianity possesses the fullness of Truth, you may find a lot more in your tradition than you expect is in harmony with the gospel - it may simply look different.. – shiningcartoonist May 23 '16 at 19:23
  • @shiningcartoonist if you would like to answer the question, please do so in an answer and not in the comments. – Andrew May 23 '16 at 22:24

There is an exclusivity about the Christian religion, properly understood, for which many Christians do not apologize.

The "founder" of the Christian religion is Christ, of course, and the claims he made about himself as recorded in the Bible leave little doubt that he considered himself to be the sine qua non of all true religion. He made seemingly outrageous statements such as,

I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to [God] the Father, except through me (John 14:6).

Jesus, unlike the founders of all the other religions in the world, did not claim to be a person who could point the way to God; he claimed to BE the way, and the only way to God. Defenders of Christ throughout history have challenged non-Christ followers to decide if Jesus was

  • A liar (Not likely, since even his enemies know that he was an honest and forthright individual who attracted loyal-to-the-death disciples because he always told the truth.)

  • A lunatic (So much good has been done in the world in the name and for the sake of Jesus Christ that even to entertain the notion that a lunatic could inspire people not only to establish hospitals, schools, orphanages, and a host of other good works designed to serve needy people worldwide, is risible!)

  • A legend (The historicity of the New Testament--the "second half" of the Bible--makes this possibility an impossibility. There is as much (and perhaps more!) historical proof for the existence of Jesus of Nazareth (Nazareth was his "hometown" in the region of Galilee in the north part of the country of Israel) as there is for perhaps any other personage from history you would care to name.)


  • The Truth personified.

One of Jesus' apostles framed a similar thought in 1 Timothy 2:4-6,

For there is one God and one mediator between God and mankind, the man Christ Jesus, who gave himself as a ransom for all people. This has now been witnessed to at the proper time.

As for the existence of "other gods," the reason why Jews and Christians believe in only one true God is because that belief is mandated by God Himself in such Bible passages as Exodus 20:1-6,

And God spoke all these words: “I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of Egypt, out of the land of slavery. “You shall have no other gods before me. “You shall not make for yourself an image in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, punishing the children for the sin of the parents to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me, but showing love to a thousand generations of those who love me and keep my commandments.

The decision to "convert" from the Hindu faith to the Christian faith is obviously a very big decision for you, fraught with all sorts of conflicting emotions. There are only two ways (of which I am aware) of converting to the Christian faith:

  1. Converting on a purely intellectual level, giving lip service to the idea that Christ is the only way to God.


  1. Converting holistically--spirit, soul, and body--to the Christian faith through what many Christians believe is the only true way of being converted; namely, through the new birth (technical word: regeneration), which requires a special intervention, if you will, on God's part (though we enter into the process with an initial step of faith, which God actually provides to the sincere-of-heart). See Jesus' words in the Gospel of John, Chapter 3, which he spoke to a very religious man who was not born again (or regenerated).

If a person of a faith which is as radically different from Christianity as Hinduism is wants to marry a Christian, a crucial question needs to be asked and answered: "Is the person I want to marry a nominal Christian (i.e., a Christian in name only, via socialization only) or a Christian by regeneration (i.e., by the new birth)?"

If the answer is yes to the former part of the question, then the implications of the Hindu's "conversion" to Christianity need only be relatively inconsequential, since nominal--not radical--followers of virtually any world religion can, in a sense, get along just fine. [Having said this, however, I realize that if people from two different religions become married, the problem of "what to raise the kids"--Hindu or Christian, for example--can be very problematic, indeed!]

If the answer to the latter part of the question is yes, then the Hindu's conversion to Christianity is a completely different matter entirely. How can a Hindu who believes in many gods believe in his or her innermost heart in the One True God (in Exodus-20 fashion)?

In conclusion, to many true (not nominal) Christians throughout the world, the exclusivity of their faith is not attributable to an ideology of man's making, but a theology of God's making, as revealed initially through the Judeo-Christian Scriptures, but ultimately in a living, breathing human being: Jesus Christ, the God-Man.

Are true Christians narrow-minded? Yes, in some things they are, and sometimes offensively (and unnecessarily!) so. The same can be said, however, of many followers of the world's religions.

As to their belief in Christ as "the way, the truth, and the life," however, Christians are required to be as narrow-minded as Christ seemed to be in his pronouncements concerning his identity as God's one and only Son, besides whom and before whom there is no other god, according to him and the Judeo-Christian Scriptures.

  • Thank you for your answer. I really liked the lip service suggestion. :) But can you please let me know if there are any liberal christian denominations which would tolerate a person like me, someone who wants to believe in Christ but also in other Gods. – Rocky May 23 '16 at 2:01
  • 2
    @Rocky: Unitarian Universalism is probably the church/religion you are looking for. I am NOT recommending you find the nearest UU church in your area and begin attending it, but UU is probably the most liberal religion in America. A local congregation would likely welcome you into their community. I strongly urge you, however, to give serious thought--not lip service--to the teachings of Jesus Christ, who claimed to BE for all time the only way to the God. He could legitimately do so because he IS God, and he is alive today in people's hearts, if they are born again. Oh, & Jesus loves YOU! – rhetorician May 23 '16 at 16:23
  • @Rocky If this woman that you love wants you to be Christian, do you suppose she'll be satisfied with UU, a non-Christian religion? She wants you to love and be faithful to her God, Yahweh. Neither she nor he will be satisfied with "lukewarm" fidelity, but you must give yourself completely to Yahweh, and you must give yourself up for her completely. My wife and I worship Yahweh together, and in our love the Spirit reveals to us the mystery of Messiah and his people. We know a peace that I pray in hope that you will find also. See Ephesians 5:22-33, Revelation 3:16, Psalm 127:1. – Andrew May 23 '16 at 22:46

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.