-3

Happy Lent!

I remember back when I was an undergrad my philo prof said that there was nothing silent about the night referred to in 'Silent Night'. Why might this be? Massacre of the Innocents? What was or was not 'silent' about that night in 'Silent Night' ?

closed as primarily opinion-based by curiousdannii, Dick Harfield, Lee Woofenden, El'endia Starman Feb 26 '16 at 8:53

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

4

If you've ever witnessed a birth, it's not exactly a silent affair. Add to this that it was a birth in a stable where there were animals presumably making all kinds of noises, you have quite the noisy affair.

So no, it's not a reference to anything beyond the idea that the carol "Silent Night" presents a rather idealized version of the nativity that just isn't particularly realistic.

This sermon covers this idea pretty well.

And yet, it’s absolutely appropriate that our Christmas Eve, that our Silent Night should be filled with sound and turmoil. It’s appropriate because that was probably the case on that first Christmas nightt. Think about it. Bethlehem was a little town with a huge heritage. All of the descendants of Jesse, the father of King David, had to return to their ancestral home for the census to be taken, and Jesse had one big family. David was one of eight sons and that was just part of one generation. Now hundreds of years later, all those descendants were coming to this little farming village of Bethlehem. It was anything but a silent night. The village overflowed with business travelers staying in strange environments. There was no more room in the inns or motels. Restaurants are booked to capacity. Energetic entrepreneurs quickly set up activities for entertainment and profit. There was a little gambling here and there. A gala party event there. Everyone looking for something to do like a family at the beach on a rainy day. Children whining. Babies crying. The teens and adults getting out of hand every now and then. We don't know everything that was going on, but I think that we can assume that it was not a silent night.

It goes on to talk about the things I mentioned in the intro, animal sounds, birthing sounds, baby jesus' cries etc.

However, this doesn't mean the song is wrong. From the same sermon:

Yet, at the same time, our favorite Christmas hymn is also right – right in every respect. On that night, Jesus did, indeed, sleep in heavenly peace. The glories did stream from heaven afar, and the heavenly hosts did sing, “Alleluia! Christ the Savior is born!” The Christ child who laid in that manger and who cuddled in His mother’s arms was – and still is – Lord at His birth.

  • I think my prof was referring to something unusual. So of course the whole world was not silent at the birth of Jesus. But perhaps there was particularly loud or unusual noise that deviated from expected noise at the time? I think what might be referred is the massacre of the innocents – BCLC Jul 21 '16 at 9:00

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.