0

Catholicism teaches ministerial priesthood (source).

Is there a concept of Ministerial Priesthood existing in Protestantism?

I'm referring to the hierarchy as well as to those who perform the sacraments. As for the scope of Protestants, I am asking those who adhere to the 5 Solae.

  • 2
    What, specifically, do you mean by "ministerial priesthood"? Are you referring to the hierarchy, the receiving of holy orders, or something else. Also, asking about all Protestants is too broad - a lot of denominations have some concept of ordained priesthood, but there is a huge variety as to what that entails. – ThaddeusB Oct 29 '15 at 15:05
  • @ThaddeusB, I'm referring to the hierarchy as well as to those who perform the sacraments. As for the scope of Protestants, I am asking those who adhere to the 5 Solae. – Radz C. Brown Oct 29 '15 at 15:07
  • @RadzMatthewCoBrown Can you edit the contents of that comment into the question please? – DJClayworth Oct 29 '15 at 16:12
  • @RadzMatthewCoBrown I'm not sure that really clears anything up. I don't know how you are distinguishing "ministerial priesthood" from simply "priesthood." Are you just trying to determine is other churches rely on ordained ministers, as opposed to ordinary Christians, to conduct church service? – ThaddeusB Oct 29 '15 at 17:58
2

There are a lot of protestant churches so it's hard to be exhaustive, but I think the Anglican Church is what you're looking for.

After splitting from Rome the Church of England went through a reformation that aligned much of their theology with the Lutheran and Calvinist traditions. You can find this in the 39 articles.

For example, this is very Protestant:

WE are accounted righteous before God, only for the merit of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ by Faith, and not for our own works or deservings

But the church's structure is very hierarchical (episcopalian) with bishops, priests, deacons, etc...

There's also the issue of Apostolic Succession which has a complicated history in the Anglican church.

To belabor the point, the lack of distinction between the Church of England and the Roman Catholic church is what led to the Puritans. In a similar vein the the Methodists broke off from the Church of England because Wesley ordained preachers and allowed them to administer the sacraments.

-1

As far as Universal Priesthood goes, there really aren't many structured rules and therefore churches and denominations that believe in Universal Priesthood are free to structure their hierarchy and perform the Eucharist however they wish.

Since the only principle it focuses on is that God is just as accessible to a new believer as He is to a pastor, elder, deacon, or whatever, the hierarchy isn't considered all that important.

The sacraments, preaching, and any other aspects of worship services can be performed however the church or denomination deems appropriate. That isn't to say that the Bible doesn't address these things at all, just that the doctrine of Universal Priesthood doesn't really address it.

Acts, Titus, and 1 Timothy, for example, talk about church leadership and and those that adhere to the 5 Solae will do their best to structure their hierarchy to fit those commands. Since the Bible itself spends a lot more time talking about the character of a good leader than it does about the hierarchy itself, you'll see a lot of churches structure themselves differently and generally maintain the belief that they have the freedom to incorporate some cultural customs like holding elections for elders and allowing congregants to vote on how to spend money rather than it being decided by elders or denominational leaders.

For the Eucharist, you'll usually see the Senior Pastor lead and an Associate Pastor assist. But even this varies pretty wildly. Many churches only have 1 pastor so they'll handle it by themselves or an elder or designated helper will assist. Many churches don't require the congregants to get up to receive the elements so ushers or other volunteers will pass the elements from pew to pew. If a pastor is out of town, in the hospital, or otherwise unavailable to lead, someone else will step in. And that person who steps in doesn't necessarily need any special training or ordination. I've even stepped in once at my church. I was notified a few days in advance that the Senior Pastor would be out of town and so I assisted the Associate Pastor. He led and I prayed over the elements. All that seems to be required in most cases is that you're in good standing with the church, you display a reverence for the process and you have an understanding of how the church handles things so you don't mess something up or do things out of order. I've also seen the elements passed at less formal services at youth camps where camp staff and counselors would lead.

You will also see the other end of the spectrum where there are denominations with very strict denominational hierarchies more comparable to what you see in Catholicism. I, personally, am less familiar with them but I believe you're more likely to find them in Lutheran and Presbyterian denominations than say Baptists or Pentecostal denominations.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.