7

Another question entitled "Do Christians and Muslims worship the same God?" requested the basis for the belief that Christians and Muslims do worship the same god.

In this question, I am requesting the basis for the belief that Christians and Muslims do not worship the same god, but worship different gods.

This question is specifically addressed to Christians who believe that Islam worships a distinctly different god, and that Judaism worships the same God as Christianity.

9
+100

The answer to your question lies in what each religion teaches about who God is.

Islam

From The Truth About Islam by Dr. David R. Reagan*:

God — The Koran asserts that the god of Islam is the God of Christians and Jews (Sura 29:46). Nothing could be farther from the truth.7

The god of Islam, Allah, is most definitely not the God of the Bible. Allah is presented in the Koran as an autocratic ruler who is aloof and arbitrary (Sura 5:40). Allah is unknowable whereas the God of the Bible is knowable (2 Timothy 1:12). Allah is impersonal, unlike the personal God the Scriptures reveal (1 Peter 5:6-7). Allah is unitarian (Sura 4:48) whereas the God of the Bible is trinitarian (2 Corinthians 13:14). Here is what the Koran says about the God of the Bible (Sura 4:171): “Believe in Allah and say not ‘Trinity.’ Cease! It is better for you! Allah is only One God. Far is it removed from his transcendent majesty that he should have a son.”

Allah is capricious (Sura 2:284), whereas the true God is trustworthy. And Allah is never anywhere presented as a god of love — which is the essence of the nature of the true God (1 John 4:7-16).

Jesus — The Koran denies point blank that Jesus was the Son of God (Sura 112:2-3). It also denies His atoning sacrifice by claiming that he never died (Sura 4:157). A substitute died for Him on the Cross. Jesus was translated to Heaven, like Enoch, where He will remain until He returns to kill all pigs, destroy all crosses, and convert the world to Islam. Jesus will marry, reign for 40 years and then die and be buried next to Muhammad in Medina.8 Jesus is characterized in the Koran as nothing more than “an apostle of Allah” (Sura 4:171).

The god that Islam teaches about is very different from the God of the Bible. Muslims and Christians may trace their roots back to Abraham but it's hard to claim they're the same god when they act so dramatically different.

Judaism

Because Christianity stems directly out of Judaism, it's clear they are worshiping the same god. The God of the New Testament is the same as the God of the Old Testament. For example:

Jesus himself even acknowledges that salvation comes from the Jews (John 4:22). Christians may believe the Jews overlooked the Messiah but they undoubtedly worship the same God.

*More info about Dr. David R. Reagan and his denominational ties can be found here: http://christinprophecy.org/?staff=dr-david-r-reagan http://christinprophecy.org/about/#Purpose

  • 1
    Thanks for adding the references. Much better! About Reagan's denominational ties, though the links are good for reference, the basic information should be included in the answer itself. In general, links should provide support for answers given, rather than providing the answers themselves. – Lee Woofenden Oct 21 '15 at 23:13
  • 1
    @coolbreeze I agree that there are big holes in the argument. But it does at least provide the basis on which one group of "Christians who believe that Islam worships a distinctly different god and Judaism worships the same God" believe as they do. Some people (including yours truly) may not think it's a very good basis, but it is their basis. – Lee Woofenden Oct 21 '15 at 23:15
  • 1
    The answer is kind of- find some scattered dissimilarities between Quran and NT, find some scattered similarities between OT and NT, then declare God of Islam and Christianity is different, while Judaism and Christianity share the same God. The better way would be, quote some complete idea of God, not scattered one liners, from sources of all three religions and then compare the similarities and dissimilarities. Then it would be seen that, idea of God in Judaism and Islam is similar(which Judaism even admits). Trinity is the splitting point, rejected by both Judaism and Islam. – Gulshan Oct 22 '15 at 2:02
  • "Because Christianity stems directly out of Judaism" - I'm pretty sure Muslims would say the same about Islam. I'm not sure the Judaism appreciates the appendages to their religion. – The Freemason Oct 22 '15 at 13:46
0

The God of the Christians/Jews is known as Yahweh (A.K.A. YHWH (or YHVH) Yahweh, Yehovah, Jehovah, and the LORD). The god of the Muslims is known as Allah. Jesus says in the Bible, the Holy Book of the Christians, in John 14:6 He is THE Way THE Truth and THE Life and no one comes to God (Yahweh) except through Him. He is the only way to God, He is the only true Savior, and the Life He gives us is True Life. Only through JESUS can you be saved and go to heaven, not through other religions. The Muslim god is therefore not the God of the Bible. No other god can get you to heaven, because they are not real. How can Allah get someone to heaven? He can't because he doesn't exist or is a demon (Deuteronomy 32:17).

For clarification: Jesus is believed by the Christians to be God in the flesh. Jesus is according to the Christians (of which I am a part of) believe Jesus is the Messiah of the Jews. Even if the Jews deny Jesus as the Messiah, Jesus is still the Messiah. God is actually a general term for a supreme deity. Whenever I use the word "God" ("G" capitalized) I am referring to YHWH. Whenever I use the word "god" ("g" not capitalized) I am referring to any false god. Allah is Arabic for God (https://translate.google.com/#en/ar/God) and Elohiym is Hebrew for God (http://www.biblestudytools.com/lexicons/hebrew/kjv/elohiym.html) although today used as a by-word or interjection (https://translate.google.com/#iw/en/%D7%90%D7%9C%D7%95%D7%94%D7%99%D7%9D).

  • I think you're on the right track. Just for clarification, because they call him Allah and not El/Eloah/Elohim/YHWH, he is either a demon or does not exist. I'm pretty sure that Judaism would not agree that YHWH's name is God or Jesus. Please add some references to your answer. – The Freemason Nov 4 '15 at 20:14
0

It's logically impossible to believe both the claims of Jesus Christ AND believe He is the same god worshiped by Islam. The truth of Jesus Christ is rooted in real-time history; not idealism, or subjectivism. (1 Corinthians 15:13-19 is all important here) IF you say you believe the God/Man Christ Jesus... a.) singularly provided atonement for our sins and b.) was physically raised from the dead YOU CANNOT THEN SAY this same God ALSO revealed Himself to Mohammed 600 years later as a being who... a.) did NOT die on the cross, and b.) was NOT raised from the dead. It's a historical, logical and even material impossibility. Let's bless our Muslim neighbors with the integrity of our love AND truth!

  • 1
    Please elaborate on how Christianity differs from Islam in regards to "real-time history; not idealism, or subjectivism". Also, from your assertion, Judaism would not worship the same God either. – The Freemason Jan 12 '16 at 14:42
  • Actually Judaism (according to Christians) DOES worship the same God, because Jesus claimed (and is) ;o) to be the God of the Old Testament. If you follow the logic of the premises I laid out in the aforementioned post, you'll logically arrive at a historical "either - or" option. It's impossible for it to be both. Blessings. – Xrucianis Jan 12 '16 at 14:47
  • Please site where Jesus claimed to be the God of the Old Testament. It gets a bit tricky when he says, "the father is greater than I", which implies distinction in John 14:28 – The Freemason Jan 12 '16 at 22:08
-2

My understanding of your question is that you are looking for the perspective of Christians who believe they worship a different deity from Muslims. So I'll give you my no. 1.

The God I serve, who is the God of the Bible, has a name, His name is Jehovah. The Lord's prayer clearly declares:

"Our Father, who is in heaven, Hallowed be thy name..."

He clearly revealed to us His name so we can use it. Inasmuch as there may be contradicting reasons as to why the name Jehovah was removed from many verses in the Bible, the consensus is that this name Jehovah was and is in the original books (taking into account tetragrammaton);

Now, from my research, I can't find the name of the deity of the Quran anywhere. And before anyone questions it, may I say Allah is not a name, it's a title? Allah is Aramaic and/or Arabic for God; Just as Dios is spanish for God. So I'm yet to hear the name of god of the Quran.

And No, I don't belong to a group or denomination; I just believe in the Bible as the inspired Word of The Living God and Jesus as His only begotten son.

Allah - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allah

Tetragrammation - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetragrammaton

The Lord's prayer by Robert Vannoy - https://goo.gl/FpnJsu

  • 1
    From reading your Tetragrammaton link, it looks like Jehovah wasn't a thing until several centuries after Christ (as opposed to the Hebrew Yahweh)? Beyond that, the Quran not mentioning a name isn't really something I'd consider a resounding argument; if I wrote a collection of things God told me to do, and just stated it as "and God said...", you wouldn't be claiming that I was referring to somebody else, would you? – Clockwork-Muse Oct 22 '15 at 12:34
  • "God" is a word / name that Jews at the time of Jesus would know either - in fact, we've reduced the names of God. Based on your assertions, I don't see how you could say that Judaism worships the same God of the Christians - which is fundamental to this question. – The Freemason Oct 22 '15 at 13:39
  • 1
    "Jehovah" is unequivocally (according to all Jewish/Hebrew scholars) not the correct pronunciation of יהוה. It comes from imposing the vocalization of אֲדֹנָי (Adonai), which means "lord", on to the tetragram because of an incorrect understanding by some medieval scholars who did not understand that the Jews wrote the adonai vocalization into the text to remind themselves not to read the sacred name. Your own link even points this out! If you are going to make an argument based on God's name, you should at least get the name right. – ThaddeusB Oct 22 '15 at 15:02
  • @ThaddeusB so few people can be bothered to look this up much less understand it. I cringe when people use that "name." – RJ Navarrete Jan 13 '16 at 1:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.