1

If one googles animals talking on Christmas Eve a wide number of hits will mention this practice.

I get the connection to the animals in the manager, but I'm trying to ascertain the origin of this Christmas legend.

Who practiced it first and when?

How widespread is it?

And, at what time does it work?

  • Is this a serious question? – BYE Dec 25 '14 at 16:58
  • 2
    Yes. This is on the "fringe" edge to be sure. But it is an old and established folk belief about Christmas that was held by Christians for many years. Like I said, I still run into it, and even I have some fun with it. – Affable Geek Dec 25 '14 at 17:01
  • Sounds more like some trickster father after reading about Balaam's donkey made it up to get the kids out in the barn while Santa Claus came. Just a thought. – BYE Dec 25 '14 at 23:03
2

Further research found this page with interesting highlights:

  1. This is primarily a Northern European/Scandanavian myth, based in the Christmas story

  2. This is a syncretic pagan tradition that melded with the Christmas story

I imagine that the talking animals business is somehow connected to the general "world turned upside down" idea of traditional winter solstice festivals, e.g. Twelfth Night:

In medieval and Tudor England, the Twelfth Night marked the end of a winter festival that started on All Hallows Eve — now more commonly known as Halloween. The Lord of Misrule symbolizes the world turning upside down. On this day the King and all those who were high would become the peasants and vice versa. At the beginning of the Twelfth Night festival, a cake that contained a bean was eaten. The person who found the bean would rule the feast. Midnight signaled the end of his rule and the world would return to normal. The common theme was that the normal order of things was reversed. This Lord of Misrule tradition dates back to pre-Christian European festivals such as the Celtic festival of Samhain and the Ancient Roman festival of Saturnalia.

  1. True to the "magnificat" animals get the upper hand, and humans often do not like what they hear. It is often used as a lesson to be kind to those lesser than themselves.

  2. It apparently works from sunset until midnight, although some variations put it at once every hundred years.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.