5

The story is, I believe, apocryphal; but the "brothers of Jesus, sons of Joseph" rejected sharing their inheritance with Jesus and James, a follower of Jesus and leader of the early church (per Acts), stated that he (James) would share one-half of his inheritance with Jesus.

  • Welcome to the site. We are glad you decided to participate. This is surely apocryphal (or you might mean Gnostic). There is only one reference to "Jesus' brothers" and it is disputed that it means literal, biological brother. Such a thing as dividing an inheritance would give the matter no doubt at all. I hope to see you post again soon. – fredsbend Sep 2 '14 at 5:35
  • Your question appears to be extra biblical, and as such becomes a truth question. It does not reflect any Denominational or primary Christian belief, and therefore I have voted to close your question. It could possibly reworded to ask if any Christian denomination adhere to such a belief, but as is is not a good fit for the site. – BYE Sep 2 '14 at 12:31
  • 6
    @Bye I disagree. The "extra biblical" texts, as you call them, have always been on-topic as part of Christian history, which has also always been on-topic. Further, the question is asking where this story is, assuming it exists, not if the story is true, which would then make it a Truth question. – fredsbend Sep 2 '14 at 17:42
2

This story is preserved in Menologion of the Holy Tradition,

When Joseph, after returning from Egypt, began to divide his land among his children born of his first wife,1 he also wished to give a portion to the Lord Jesus Who was born supernaturally and without corruption of the all-pure Virgin Mary, and Who was then but a little child. But three of Joseph's sons did not wish Christ to have a share, as He was born of another mother; only the fourth son, St. James, accepted Him as co-owner of his own portion, and hence was afterwards called the "Brother of God."

St. Dimitri of Rostov, Menologion, trans. Isaac E. Lambertsen, The Lives of the Holy Apostles, Holy Apostles Convent: Buena Vista, CO, 1988, p. 223-4.


1 "Salome, daughter of Haggai, the son of Barachiah, a brother of Saint Zacharias, the father of the holy Prophet John the Forerunner of the Lord." St. Dimitri of Rostov, Menologion, 223.

1

The story presupposes that Joseph had sons, so we can probably exclude the Western church in our search for the source. Catholic tradition came to hold Jerome’s ‘cousins’ theory of Jesus’ relation to James and his siblings, none of them children of Joseph.

The story further suggests that James was Joseph’s eldest son; as primogenitor he would have received a double-share of the inheritance and so able to share half with Jesus. This excludes the Helvidian view – that Jesus was the eldest of Joseph and Mary’s children – and instead points to the Epiphanian view, held by the Eastern Orthodox churches, that James etal were children of Joseph by a marriage prior to Mary, and so older than Jesus.

Since the Eastern Orthodox tradition is more likely to have preserved this story, our search for its specific source might focus there.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.