0

I would like to know where Catholics got the idea that Mary was born without original sin. I know it's Church dogma from early on but how did it get started, and what was the reasoning? And do Protestants universally reject this?

Was she the only human to have been born this way besides Adam and Jesus?

Improve this question
4
  • 2
    I believe it's incorrect to say it is "dogma" from early on, I believe it was only proclaimed in an ex cathedra fashion in the 19th Century.
    – bruised reed
    Commented May 28, 2014 at 16:35
  • 1
    You have more than one question here but the gist of the question is in scope for the duplicate. If you would like to ask a focused question narrowing in on some part that is not covered in the duplicate that would be fine. "Do Protestants universally reject the immaculate conception" for example might make a good stand alone question. A specific question about dates of official dogma might also work, just the general "why" question is covered (or should be encouraged to be covered in the original question).
    – Caleb
    Commented May 28, 2014 at 18:04
  • @bruisedreed: Yes, that's right. Many believed it before Pope Pius IX solemnly defined it dogma in 1854 in Ineffabilis Deus.
    – Geremia
    Commented May 30, 2014 at 16:09
  • @GregoryMagarshak: Ineffabilis Deus also gives the reasons for why Pope Pius IX defined it as dogma.
    – Geremia
    Commented May 30, 2014 at 16:10

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
2

What was the reasoning?

There are many reasons given by the Church Fathers. Some of them are:

  • Mary is the new Eve. Since Jesus is the new Adam (Romans 5:12-18), Mary is the new eve foretold in Genesis 3:15. God foretold that she would be eternally at enmity with the evil serpent. So if she was touched by sin then this enmity will not be possible.
  • She is the mother of God. It would be better for God to save her before falling then after. (After all He is the one who commanded to honor thy father and mother)

The great Franciscan theologian, Duns Scotus, explained ca. 600 years ago that falling into sin could be likened to a man approaching unaware a massive 20-feet deep ditch. If he falls into the ditch, he would need someone to lower a rope and save him. But if someone were to warn him of the danger ahead resulting in the man not falling into the ditch at all, he would have been saved from falling in the first place. Analogously, Mary was saved from sin by receiving the grace to be preserved from it. But she was still saved.

  • She is seen as a type of the Ark of the Covenant. Like the Ark which was protected from impure touch (2 Samuel 6:7), Mary is considered to be protected from Original Sin. (There are other similarities between Mary and the Ark too)

  • She is called Full of Grace by God the Father. Here the word grace (kecharitōmenē) is perfect passive participle. This word — kecharitōmenē, means not only full of grace, but the grace was bestowed in the past to the fullest extant possible and is ongoing. This is interpreted to mean she is sinless. Because Grace cannot be full if there is sin.

And do Protestants universally reject this?

It depends on what you mean by Protestants. But most protestants do not accept it. But some protestants like Anglo-Lutherans do.

Was she the only human to have been born this way besides Adam and Jesus?

Officially (at-least according to Catholics) we know for sure that Jesus and Mary were born sinless (Adam was created sinless). But some believe St. John the baptist, even though conceived in original sin, was purified in womb during visitation, making him technically sinless when born. Some also include St. Joseph in this list. But these are not official dogmas and one may choose not to believe in them.

Improve this answer
2
  • But if the wages of sin is death and Mary wasn't under original sin, how do Catholics explain that she seems to have died a normal human death?
    – Gregory Magarshak
    Commented May 28, 2014 at 18:14
  • To @GregoryMagarshak : Please see How could a sinless Mary die?. In short Easter Christians do not believe she died. In the West they believe that since her son Jesus died, Mary chose to die to imitate Him even though she didn't have to.
    – Jayarathina Madharasan
    Commented May 28, 2014 at 18:18

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .