According to TULIP Calvinism grace is "irresistible". If grace is irresistible then what role does faith play in salvation and can it still be considered a gift?

  • 5
    If someone slips $20 in your pocket without you noticing would you call that a gift? (that's not the best example here, but that's a similarly irresistible gift).
    – wax eagle
    Jul 17, 2013 at 20:03
  • I think these are basically the same: Why is “faith” omitted as a doctrinal consideration in TULIP (five point) Calvinism?
    – user3961
    Jul 17, 2013 at 23:50
  • @fredsbend I asked him to ask a new question because the answers seemed to not be getting at what he wanted. Is there a way to edit the old one to make it fit the answers he got a bit better?
    – wax eagle
    Jul 18, 2013 at 3:15
  • @waxeagle I am not trying to be smart but I wonder if a love is irresistible is it then forced and forced love is a form of rape.
    – Rick
    Jul 18, 2013 at 17:05
  • 1
    Is life a gift?
    – user3797
    Jul 26, 2013 at 21:08

2 Answers 2


Yes, salvation can still be considered a gift. In general, something can be considered a gift if it:

  • Is positive/desirable
  • Is given rather than earned (otherwise it should be called a wage)
  • Is given without obligation of repayment (otherwise it should be called a loan)

Whether a gift can be resisted or not has no bearing on its "giftiness". According to Calvinism, faith comes into play as the mode with which we receive the gift of salvation. So, in order to cause us to be saved, God regenerates us and then causes us to have faith.

The irresistible quality of the process (regeneration and subsequent faith) does not undermine it's "giftiness". On the contrary. According to Calvinism, salvation would not be purely a gift if it were resistible, because then the act of choosing to not resist the gift could be construed as meritoriously earning it, at least in part.

  • @Eric What scriptures support grace being irresistible? A gift faithfully received is not a credit to the faithful but to the gift giver.
    – Rick
    Jul 19, 2013 at 21:02
  • @Rick, I'm not a Calvinist, and I personally don't think there's a good case for grace being irresistible. But, in general, the notion of resistibility does not contradict the notion of giftiness. Understanding the Biblical case for irresistible grace is a separate question.
    – user971
    Jul 20, 2013 at 20:47

It seems the answers here created this question.

In Calvinism the grace is that God gives you faith, which then saves you.

You are elected to receive that grace without condition. Nothing you do, could do, have done, or anything to do with you or your actions was weighed in determining your election. That is why is is called unconditional election.

That is the very definition of a gift. You are receiving something that you do not deserve, nor did you earn, nor will you have to do anything to keep it. You were elected to receive the gift of faith through the grace of God.

Because that grace is irresistible is irrelevant to the fact that is is still a gift that you did not deserve. What you did deserve is death and hellfire. Instead God has poured out His grace on you, which gave you the faith to believe. You have then been saved by faith through His irresistible grace.

To clarify things, here is the chronology of events:

  1. You are unconditionally elected to receive grace. You did not do anything to deserve or earn this grace. Receiving it was by the will of God alone and had nothing to do with you.
  2. God pours that grace upon you. This is the gift. You do not deserve it. It so happens that it is irresistible and you will accept it.
  3. The grace of God works in you and builds faith in you.
  4. You then freely and willingly come to God because of that faith within you. You are officially saved by grace through faith.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .