5

There are thousands of Christian denominations. How did these groups form?

What is the typical process for organizing a denomination?

1
  • 2
    This is far too general a question, you might as well ation of counties through world history. The reasons and processes are legion. Without demonstrating why the answer matters, there is nothing to focus on and answering is going to be an exercise in pin the tail on the donkey. What do you need to come away knowing and why?
    – Caleb
    Jun 12, 2013 at 20:14

3 Answers 3

18

Not to be flip, but it sort of goes like this:

  1. Find some theological point on which you find your existing denomination to be so heretical as to be in grave danger of going to hell. Assume this point is not aidaphora.

  2. Find a bunch of other people who agree, and start meeting together.

  3. Possibly, ordain yourself (as in the case of Joseph Smith - the founder of the LDS denomination, or Joseph Smythe - traditionally considered the founder of the Baptists) or if you already have been ordained (e.g. Richard Allen, founder of the AME Church after being nearly beaten senseless in his home church or the Episcopalian Church in general after the American Revolution) convince a court that you are not, in fact part of your former denomination.

  4. Start forming more than one church, so that you actually are a group of churches, rather than just a splinter one.

Ultimately, the only two entities that you will probably care about are:

  1. Your home denomination - you don't want them claiming you, right? Just send them a letter saying you are no longer part of them. If you publicly repudiate them, so much the better! The point is simple enough - your adherence to a given church is completely voluntary. Any way in which you no longer volunteer will suffice.

  2. The IRS. Here's what most groups in the US care about - the tax exemption. Truth is, it doesn't actually matter to the IRS either. If you want to call yourself "The Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster," you just need to convince the IRS you are church. If you affiliate with anyone else, it helps, but ultimately, they don't really decide.

Like nations, each denomination is simply a sovereign entity unto itself. If you try to call yourself "the Roman Catholic Church," there is an entity and an institution that will say, "No you are not." But if you want to start your own, there is no one to stop you.

In the end, denominations - even highly organized ones - are voluntary associations of like-minded individuals. There is no authority - in fact, there isn't even an agreed on definition of denominations. Scholars simply use the label to distinguish like-minded groups from one another.

11

Generally denominations form over church splits or mergers, rather than just appearing from scratch.

The denomination I am a part of the PCA formed in the 70s after the mainline Presbyterian church (PCUSA) took a more liberal leaning than many of the southern Presbyterian churches were willing to go along with. They left and formed their own denomination.

Generally you need two things for a denomination, although neither are required. You need a group of churches and you need a central authority. For the PCA, they had a group of churches ready and willing to leave their denomination a form a new body. They had a convention in Birmingham and organized a General Assembly that meets every year to determine doctrine, policy and mission going forward. The Presbyterian model is a representative form of government with individual churches reporting to regional councils which then report to national governing bodies.

Groups of unaffiliated (non-denominational) churches who think alike might also want to form denominations in order to have associations with a larger national organizations. These churches might choose to organize in a congregational manner, giving their congregations a significant amount of autonomy.

0
0

One way to start a denomination is to observe a defining moment in history that needs a response from the church, but the church is not giving. Unfortunately in the USA, denominations have split over political and economic reasons, such as the Southern Baptist Convention over offense at the larger body not wanting to ordain a slaveholder.

I was raised in a then called American Baptist church. The SBC is the 2nd largest Christian denomination in the US, 2nd to the Roman Catholic church. Unfortunately the splits continue today with militant adherence to "north/south" "pro/anti" positions. These do not reflect the mission of a Christian church, such as to "go and make disciples" or be united (John 17; Matt. 28).

To validate your question: there is a huge need to revamp or change what is. Also, nondenominational while a dodge to these concerns can still reflect more ideology than mission. You don't necessarily know what the church in practice believes even if the doctrine statements look squeaky clean.

So it is not trite or flip at all. Even if we think the issues that people make denominations out of are odd, we are not separate from it, as if nondenominational gives us a pass.

I have done research on ecumenical partnership, which is one way to be united as a church at the local level.

I think a new denomination is needed. People are leaving denominational and nondenominational churches because of the tainted witness of the past few years. So whatever the organization, it will need to address the rift and heresies upheld by many in church leadership, and be a healthy church.

This means accountability for racism, sexual predatory practices, and abuse. People including pastors have violated sacred trust of their role by engaging in or ignoring or denying these practices. This is less opinion and more based on numbers, e.g., Pew Research, Oxfam, and credible Christian humanitarian or nonprofit working to address these, and anecdotal expectations from people who have survived trauma in the church. Just observing the strife from 2020 to present shows something new can provide a solution.

To sum, you can start a denomination based on need at a moment in history. A study of church history can help.

I am in the process of creating a denomination. Reach out if you want to learn more.

1
  • Welcome to the C.SE! Thanks for your contribution. As a new visitor, I'd recommend checking out the following: How we are different than other sites? Your post does not really answer the question, which is simply asking how a new denomination begins. It is not meant to be the beginning of a discussion on creating new denomations.
    – user54757
    Mar 29, 2022 at 1:32

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .