There's a teaching called "Hell's Best Secret" that's been circulating for several years, originally preached by Ray Comfort, the a New Zealand-born minister, and founder of Living Waters Publications.

Without going into whether or not the teaching is true, what is the primary message of the teaching, the Scriptural basis, and its influence?

  • As always, even though I self-answered, I'm more than willing to vote up and even accept better answers. Commented Oct 6, 2012 at 20:38
  • This might be of interest.
    – luchonacho
    Commented Jan 3, 2018 at 12:00
  • It would be very helpful to have an explicit definition of what the actual "secret" is. Commented Sep 26, 2019 at 14:20

2 Answers 2


The Hell's Best Secret teaching is essentially a denouncement on what Ray Comfort calls "the modern Gospel", and a teaching on what he considers the proper use of Mosaic Law to prepare the heart for the Gospel.

Early on in the message, he speaks of a certain denomination's evangelism efforts during what they called "the decade of Harvest":

Let me make it more real for you. In 1991, in the first year of the decade of harvest, a major denomination in the U.S. was able to obtain 294,000 decisions for Christ. That is, in one year, this major denomination of 11,500 churches was able to obtain 294,000 decisions for Christ. Unfortunately, they could only find 14,000 in fellowship, which means they couldn’t account for 280,000 of their decisions, and this is normal, modern evangelical results

According to Comfort, based on Church records that he's had access to, something like 80%-90% of those who have "been saved" later fall away. He blames this on the methods used to get people to come to Christ.

The "Modern Gospel" as he calls it, is one of life enhancement. Sinners are promised that God can heal their broken marriage, fix their drug problems, alcohol problems, and so forth. The "Modern Gospel" is, according to Comfort, a misguided attempt to make Christianity appealing by showing how much better the Christian life is than that of the unsaved.

He uses an illustration of a man on an airplane, who is given a parachute and is told that it would improve his flight, to illustrate how foolish this is.

Comfort argues:

Now listen to what the modern gospel says. It says, “Put on the Lord Jesus Christ. He’ll give you love, joy, peace, fulfillment, and lasting happiness.” In other words, “Jesus will improve your flight.” So the sinner responds, and in an experimental fashion, puts on the Savior to see if the claims are true. And what does he get? The promised temptation, tribulation, and persecution. The other passengers mock him. So what does he do? He takes off the Lord Jesus Christ, he’s offended for the word’s sake (Mark 4:17), he’s disillusioned and somewhat embittered, and quite rightly so. He was promised peace, joy, love, fulfillment, and lasting happiness, and all he got were trials and humiliation. His bitterness is directed toward those who gave him the so-called “good news”. His latter end becomes worse than the first: another inoculated and bitter backslider.

The rest of the teaching expands on the proper use of the Law, particularly the The pedagogical use (although he doesn't use that term in the teaching), which is to show sinners what sin is, to show them that they are, indeed, sinners, and show them their need of a Savior, and allow repentance. Without the Law, He argues (as does the Apostle Paul), sinners don't even know what sin is. How can they repent, if they don't know what sin is?

The teaching contains a section in which he illustrates using the Ten Commandments on an unrepentant sinner to show them their sinful nature in it's true light.

I say, “Ah, do you think you’ve kept the ten commandments?” He says, “Ah, yeah…pretty much.” I say, “Let’s go through them. Ever told a lie?” He says, “Ah, yeah…yeah, one or two.” I say, “What does that make you?” He says, “A sinner.” I say, “No, no. Specifically, what does it make you?” He says, “Well, man, I’m not a liar.” I say, “How many lies, then, do you have to tell to be a liar? Ten and a bell rings and ‘ppppbbbbtttt’ across your forehead? Isn’t it true if you tell one lie, it makes you a liar?” He says, “Yeah…I guess you’re right.” I say, “Have you ever stolen something?” He says, “No.” I say, “Come on; you’ve just admitted to me you’re a liar.” I say, “Ever stolen something, even if its small?” and he says, “Yeah.” I say, “What does that make you?” He says, “A thief.” I say, “Jesus said, ‘If you look at a woman and lust after her, you commit adultery with her in your heart’ (Mat. 5:28).

Ever done that?” He says, “Yeah, plenty of times.” “Then from your own admission, you’re a lying, thieving, adulterer at heart, and you have to face God on judgment day; and we’ve only looked at three of the ten commandments. There’s another seven with their cannons pointed at you. Have you used God’s name in vain?” “Yeah…I’ve been trying to stop.” “You know what you’re doing? Instead of using a four-letter filth word beginning with ‘s’ to express disgust, you’re using God’s name in its place. That’s called blasphemy; and the Bible says, ‘Every idle word a man speaks he’ll give account thereofon the day of judgment’ (Mat. 12:36). ‘The Lord will not old him guiltless who takes his name in vain’ (Ex. 20:7). The Bible says if you hate someone, you are a murderer (1 John 3:15).”

The main point of the teaching is that instead of using promises of a better life to lure sinners to accepting Christ, we need to use God's law to show them their need for Christ, and drive them to the Savior.

As for the influence it's had in recent years:

While it's debatable whether Comfort's message is true, and it's not universally accepted, there's no denying that it has been widely accepted, and influential.

I personally first heard of the teaching at a Baptist Church, where a member gave me a cassette version of the audio teaching. I have since been presented with it from members of Assembly of God, Evangelical Free, and Independent Bible Churches. It's a teaching that's steadily gaining acceptance in a wide variety of denominations, although I've never seen it endorsed officially by any organization.

A few years back, Kirk Cameron (the actor) joined him in trying to spread the teaching, and as a result of Kirk's celebrity, the teaching has become even more popular.

The teaching has had influence in a number of well-known Christian movies, such as the Left Behind movies, Fireproof, and Courageous. In each of these movies, at least one character is seen using the same basic "have you ever told a lie" use of the law to speak to an unsaved person.

They've also been both on the radio and on Christian TV - with the Way of the Master radio, and The Way of the Master television show, and I've even heard the message preached on the ultra-conservative VCY America radio.


The teaching is an endorsement of using the Ten Commandments in witnessing to break up the stony soil of the heart and prepare it to receive the seed of the Gospel. Scripture tells us it is the Holy Spirit's tool and that he uses it to convict the heart with Godly sorrow....a necessary state for the Gospel seed to take root. Many scriptures assure us it's power and the spiritual giants of the past endorsed it as crucial. For what it's worth, the Lord made an 'believer' out of me of this message's content before I had even heard it by placing in my heart the validity of the teaching (to come to my ears, shortly after) with the verse, Gal. 3:24 "Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith." My walk with Christ has never been the same. This was the answer to my heart-cry for ammo to speak with the unsaved, because, when speaking to them before 'discovering' this BIBLICAL method, my witnessing attempts came across as self-righteous, judgmental or downright silly...because they were! Now, by using the Law, it makes the Gospel make sense, acting as 'salt', causing the unsaved to 'thirst' for the living water of Jesus. Salt and light is what we are to be, and since "Faith comes by hearing and hearing by the Word of God", preaching this biblical method of conviction is being salt and light to this dying world.

  • Welcome to the site! This next has nothing to do with the quality of your answer, it's just standard to help new visitors avoid misunderstanding the site (as I did at first.) As a new visitor, I'd recommend checking out the following two posts, which are meant to help newcomers "learn the ropes": the help page and How we are different than other sites? Commented Jan 19, 2014 at 22:02

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .