2,648 reputation
52062
bio website
location Taiwan
age
visits member for 3 years, 10 months
seen 21 mins ago

I often chose best answers not because they are the best, but because I have to choose a best answer. Please, don't take offense to it.


May
19
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
But... isn't it like all the early Church Fathers, when speaking about the story of presentation of Mary draw that story from the Protevangelium?
May
19
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
@MattGutting - "The belief is buttressed by its presence in the Protevangelium, but that doesn't mean they accept the book as a whole as part of their tradition" - In other words, they have some other sources besides the Protevangelium that tells them about that story, right?
May
19
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
@MattGutting - "It sounds as if you're asking how these churches decided to choose books for their canon" - No. Apocrypha are by definition not part of canon. I am asking about how they decide which Apocrypha they still keep as a part of their tradition, and which Apocrypha they don't consider to be a part of their tradition.
May
19
revised Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
added 750 characters in body; edited title
May
19
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
You might want to expand on your answer - I just edited my question. My original intention in it was not to ask about what an Apocrypha is, but rather about what Apocrypha are the part of the Catholic or the Orthodox traditions and which ones are not.
May
19
revised Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
added 750 characters in body; edited title
May
19
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
Ah, I got it now. Thanks for the clarification.
May
19
asked Do the Orthodox pray to John the Baptist?
May
18
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
So where in my words have you seen my "historic relativism"? And what did you mean by saying "I raise you one Council of Nicaea"? Did you mean to say "I refer you to the Council of Nicaea"?
May
18
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
I see your historic relativism and raise you one Council of Nicaea - What do you mean?!
May
17
awarded  Popular Question
May
17
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
"Each church decided which books were going into their bible, and if they didn't, the book is not holy to them by definition" - Well, this is at least not true about the Orthodox Church. They consider many books outside of the canon to be the part of their Holy Tradition and believe whatever is written in them and don't question the validity of the events described in them.
May
16
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
@Steve - "If the works are not considered part of their canon, then they are by definition not Apocrypha" - I am quite confused by this statement. Do you mean to say that the cannon is consisted only of Apocrypha?! "Perhaps you are asking whether there are any more holy or inspired works than those in the Catholic Bible?" - I am asking about if there are any Apocrypha (like "Acts of Andrew", "Gospel of Mary", etc.) that are not considered by Catholics and the Orthodox to be part of their canons and yet are considered by them to be the part of their holy tradition.
May
16
comment Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
@kutschkem - "By apocrypha, do you mean those that are in the bible?" - No. I mean those that are NOT in the Bible.
May
16
asked Which Apocrypha are part of the Catholic and the Orthodox traditions and which are not? Why?
May
13
comment In the parable of the ten minas, why does the king kill his enemies?
@Andrew - I could've, but I forgot where exactly I came across that interpretation.
May
3
awarded  Popular Question
May
1
awarded  Famous Question
Apr
28
revised What is the scriptural basis for the idea that salvation can still be obtained after death?
deleted 239 characters in body
Apr
28
asked How do Congregationalists explain 1st Tim 1:3 and Titus 1:5?