2,111 reputation
625
bio website
location
age
visits member for 1 year, 9 months
seen Feb 23 at 22:31

Sep
4
comment Water Baptism - Is it still necessary?
Hello @McGafter. From your profile, it looks like you're new to Christianity.SE. While we all have our own beliefs about who gets the Bible right, and who gets it wrong, you might find the meta post "Brothers, we are not Christians!" to be informative re what C.SE is about. Take care.
Aug
31
comment Why did Protestants abandon Liturgy of the Hours?
@Narnian: What do you think?
Aug
31
comment Why did Protestants abandon Liturgy of the Hours?
[…]offering a prayer that was previously composed by someone with a great gift for prayer would be displeasing to God. I find that idea troubling, as I've encountered people who are new to the faith and to prayer, and who have been very discouraged when they've heard that their efforts to communicate with God and their use of others' words to learn how to pray (see, for example, Luther’s Prayers, Ed. Herbert Brokering… or Mt 6:9-13, for that matter) could be rejected by the same God whom they’re trying to please, and the Bible instead teaches that Christians should encourage faith in others.
Aug
30
comment Why did Protestants abandon Liturgy of the Hours?
Hi Narnian. Do you happen to have any references for that application of Mt 6:7? I've checked several commentaries and looked at the Greek (esp. G945 "βαττολογέω"), and found that 1) many commentators seem to be in basic agreement re Mt 6:7; & 2) of the ones that I was able to check, none exegeted the verse to refer to the offering of prayers written by others. While it may or may not be too much of a stretch to apply the verse to monastic chanting, this post seems -- at least to me -- to further suggest that […]
Aug
24
comment Does 1 Corinthians 9:27 contradict the doctrine of “The Perseverance of the Saints?”
@Ovi: John MacArthur gave an answer in a Q&A session at a conference (Ligonier, 2008) that's germane to questions re assurance, also. The question was actually about legalism, but here's a link to the portion where Dr. MacArthur briefly discusses the characteristics that distinguish "real" Christians from nominal Christians. You can find more resources on assurance from Ligonier here.
Aug
17
comment Does 1 Corinthians 9:27 contradict the doctrine of “The Perseverance of the Saints?”
Hi @Ovi. Having a lack of assurance re one's own salvation is actually a very common issue. Lots of books have been written on the subject. If you want to learn about assurance, here's a quick article from John Piper to start with. Beyond that, answering specific question about such doctrines is what C.SE is for, so you might want to ask some more questions. Ciao.
Aug
14
comment Does John Piper identify himself as a “five point,” or as a “four point” Calvinist?
Thanks, OnesimusUnbound. I think you're right that John Piper is a five-point Calvinist. +1.
Aug
14
comment Any mentions of Environmental protection in Bible?
Responsible use of resources would fall under the general category of "stewardship." See Nave's and Torrey's. Some pundits have observed that there are interpretation of "environmentalism" which seem similar to earth-worship, which would be idolatry. Different people have different understandings of where the line should be drawn between various interpretations.
Aug
13
comment Does John Piper identify himself as a “five point,” or as a “four point” Calvinist?
Btw, the "Canons of Dordt" thing is just some historical context that I added to the question; it's the source of what today is called "5 point Calvinism" or "TULIP," but people rarely use the historical names.
Aug
13
comment Does John Piper identify himself as a “five point,” or as a “four point” Calvinist?
Someone said Piper was a 4 point Calvinist during a conversation at a fellowship group. Another person agreed, and I've seen the same repeated online, but those making the "4 point" claim never cite any sources. As one who listens to Piper regularly, I find the "four point" claim difficult to believe, and wanted to clear things up.
Aug
13
comment Is Partialism a real heresy?
@waxeagle: Looks like it didn't change to Community Wiki as I thought it might, so reverting isn't necessary. Thank you, though.
Aug
11
comment Did John Calvin teach that God creates certain souls only to be destroyed?
If you would like to get the answer from Calvin himself, go here: Institutes, Book 3, Ch. 21. More: Many references at Monergism; A very readable summary from U. of Oregon's history dept.; Two documents on predestination that Reformed.org claims were written by Calvin.
Aug
11
comment Did John Calvin teach that God creates certain souls only to be destroyed?
You're looking for information on "double predestination," or reprobation. It's difficult to give a simple "yes" or "no" answer, primarily because of the various subtleties of that doctrine. A comprehensive / exhaustive answer would also consider elements of supralapsarianism / infralapsarianism. One of the few people with a commanding understanding of both, as well as of the teachings of Calvin, is R.C. Sproul; he has an article on "double predestination" that answers your question here.
Aug
9
comment How could a seventh century heretic have possessed papal infallibility?
Papal infallibility says that every person to hold the office of Pope was capable of speaking ex cathedra, regardless of whether or not an individual actually made use of the authority, doesn't it?
Aug
5
comment What scriptures talk about the survival of fish and sea animals during the flood?
Related C.SE content: 1, 2, 3.
Aug
3
comment Is hypocrisy a sin?
@ZettaSuro: If you have questions about how to reconcile verses that command rebuke with those which require humility, that might be something to ask on the main board. I think that would be better than talking about it in comments. Thanks.
Jul
29
comment Does a classic Trinitarian formulation consider God to be his own “Family”?
@Rick: Not that anyone asked my opinion, but I suppose that if I were tasked with teaching the Doctrine of the Trinity at an "uncomplicated level," part of my explanation would likely be to offer a survey of the different analogies from throughout history, then explain when, why, and how each analogy was rejected, then reiterate the applicable Biblical texts, and clarify with documents such as the Nicene and Athanasian Creeds. The important part, from looking at 2,000 years of history, seems to be that the Trinity is a mystery, and defies naturalistic explanation.
Jul
29
comment What did Jonathan Edwards have to say about the fact that he owned slaves?
Apparently Edwards the Younger was the ninth of Edwards' twelve children. I didn't know that. Thanks.
Jul
28
comment Can you give some example passage that is not so easy to decide whether to interpret the passage literally or metaphorically?
@laovultai: I think your suggested edit would be a clear improvement. Ultimately it's up to the community, with high-rep users as the community's representatives, to decide which questions are / are not placed on hold or reopened following improvement. The overall idea is to phrase questions in a way that they can be answered by reference to external standards, rather than individual users' interpretations.
Jul
28
comment Can you give some example passage that is not so easy to decide whether to interpret the passage literally or metaphorically?
Hi @laovultai, I offered an edit that gives the question a more specific scope. You can find answers to your question here and here. Thanks.