Reputation
2,556
Top tag
Next privilege 3,000 Rep.
Cast close & reopen votes
Badges
10 24
Newest
 Yearling
Impact
~167k people reached

Jan
31
comment Would restoring Christian worship to Biblical Christianity necessitate the removal of the Bible from those churches?
It's widely thought that the gospels were written down for the precise reason that the Church could no longer rely on eye-witnesses. So to restore the earliest Christian tradition you'd need some eye-witnesses to give their stories of Christ. They tend to be thin on the ground and the gospels are probably the next best thing.
Nov
16
comment How do Catholics believe God is eternal if Jesus died on the cross?
I don't have the references to hand to write an answer, but the orthodox Catholic answer would be to say that Christ died according to his human nature not according to the divine nature. The same applies with impassibility & suffering. Many theologians (famously Tertullian) would say that we can say "God died" by virtue of the communication of attributes. Ultimately this is one of the paradoxes of the Christian faith generally and Christology particularly.
Nov
14
comment Why is Jesus named the Prince of Peace instead of the King of Peace?
In the foreword to the KJV, King James was addressed as the most high and mightie Prince, James. This was very much the sense of the word in this era of English; all other uses of "Prince of Peace" are derivative.
Oct
15
comment In Catholicism, what is the proper order of the sacraments of initiation and what are the summary arguments in support of this order?
@Marc Certainly. But the idea of a Bar Mitzvah has changed in the intervening 1945 years, so the modern rite of confirmation is not closely related to the modern Bar Mitzvah. Moreover, I know of no particular evidence to say that confirmation was in any way seen as a fulfilment of the Bar Mitzvah; on the contrary, it was originally part of baptism.
Oct
15
comment In Catholicism, what is the proper order of the sacraments of initiation and what are the summary arguments in support of this order?
@Marc Confirmation is not a descendant/fulfilment of the Bar Mitzvah. It existed before the modern understanding of the Bar Mitzvah came into being.
Oct
15
comment In Catholic evening prayer, why do some days have Psalm prayers, other days do not?
My copy of the Liturgy of the Hours has no psalm prayers at all. Which specific book are you using?
Aug
24
awarded  Yearling
Aug
15
answered Why was Jesus afraid/agonizing in the Garden of Gethsemane if the Spirit of God isn't one of fear but of power?
Aug
15
comment What is the means of forgiveness in Purgatory?
Purgatory, in traditional Catholic doctrine, is not about forgiveness but about purification.
Aug
8
comment Why do Anglicans kneel when Catholics would stand?
Anglicans almost universally stand for the Collect, except in old-fashioned BCP services.
Jul
25
comment What is truly meant when it is said that Holy Scripture is 'inerrant' according to the Catholic Church?
Where precisely do you find the statement that the Catholic Church considers the scriptures infallible and inerrant?
Jul
16
revised Do the Orthodox and Catholic Churches allow participation in each others' services?
RC unavailable
Jul
16
comment Do the Orthodox and Catholic Churches allow participation in each others' services?
@JAGAnalyst That would be all Orthodox churches, then... You're quite right, however, that the Catholic point refers to circumstances when a Catholic mass is unavailable; I'll add that to my answer.
Jul
16
comment Do the Orthodox and Catholic Churches allow participation in each others' services?
@JAGAnalyst Read the whole page. Specifically the the paragraphs above the asterisks.
Jul
15
answered Do the Orthodox and Catholic Churches allow participation in each others' services?
Jul
9
comment Do Anglo-Catholics encourage closed Communion?
The RCC does not, strictly speaking, have a closed-communion policy in that members of Orthodox churches are permitted to receive, though most don't. However, I know of no Anglican church that would have even a similar policy.
Jan
20
comment Why are the Psalms numbered this way in some Catholic Bibles?
Do you mean, why are the psalms in the order they're in?
Jan
14
comment What did Pilate mean by asking “What is truth?”
I've always read this as irony looking at John 14.6, yes.
Jan
12
comment Can Man see God?
@bruisedreed Though the general point (i.e. that different theologies exist, so we shouldn't necessarily expect utter consistency) is a decent one. You don't need Wellhausen's theory per se to consider that point valid.
Jan
11
comment Is all prayer supplication?
@user3293056 You might see a section in that CCC link, ¶2623: "Blessing expresses the basic movement of Christian prayer: it is an encounter between God and man." That seems a good summary to me, though doubtless there are many others.