Hot answers tagged homosexuality
33
From Romans 1, we understand that homosexual activity is a result of a people who know God, but choose not to glorify Him as God. In other words, it is a symptom of a society that has rejected God.
From a theological point of view, a Christian could oppose gay marriage on the grounds that his government is, acting on his behalf, calling "evil good and good ...
29
There's an entire Wikipedia post regarding this subject. (Thus it's my source as it's easily referenced.)
1
Leviticus 20:13 is the first:
13 “‘If a man has sexual relations with a man as one does with a
woman, both of them have done what is detestable. They are to be put
to death; their blood will be on their own heads.
2
Genesis 18-19 has the ...
18
In addition to Richard's post, it's important to keep Acts 15 in mind.
The clearest and most unambiguous prohibitions against homosexual acts in the Bible come from the Law of Moses. It's frequently pointed out that the Law was fulfilled in Christ and Christians aren't expected to be held to its many precepts and prohibitions, such as being forbidden to ...
18
The motivations for protests against homosexuality differ based on the group, and as such the answers must be tailored to the groups. It should also be mentioned that overall (meaning as a percentage) relatively few Christians tend to take part in these protests, for precisely the reason you state.
Furthermore, there are several Christian denominations ...
18
You are correct in stating that there are no recorded teachings of Jesus on homosexuality. However, to suggest that this means there is disagreement between Paul and Jesus is unreasonable, since it is comparing something to nothing. It is certainly wrong to assume that Jesus disagreed with Paul on that just because He never explicitly indicates His ...
17
1. What you "are" is irrelevant
Let us first distinguish between being a member of a class - in this case homosexuals - and engaging in any sort of behavior. For many people, being a member of the class "homosexual" means having feelings in one direction or another. In no event would a "temptation" towards a certain behavior be taken as exclusion.
James ...
14
In general
Romans 12:16-21 (ESV)
16 Live in harmony with one another. Do not be haughty, but associate with the lowly. Never be wise in your own sight. 17 Repay no one evil for evil, but give thought to do what is honorable in the sight of all. 18 If possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all. 19 Beloved, never avenge yourselves, ...
12
If we believed that Christianity was merely a good way to live, then there might be a justification for simply adhering to a "live and let live" philosophy such as it pertains to society and social issues. But it's not; rather Christianity is the expression of God's plan of salvation for a fallen creation, and our moral code is the expression of God's ...
12
John Piper recently addressed a portion of this question in the context of Minnesota's "Same-Sex Marriage Amendment". Having listened to his sermons on Romans 1 and other statements by him, the following principles are his consistent teaching on the question:
Marriage is created and defined by God in the Scriptures as the sexual and covenantal union ...
10
Jesus said to keep the commandments, including the commandment against Adultery (Matthew 19:16–19)
The commandments against adultery form the basis for the Catholic teaching against homosexual acts and all sexual acts outside of marriage. These teachings all fall under an explanation of the sixth commadnment:
Chastity and homosexuality
...
9
I think you've given a very good argument why it's implausible to theorize that homosexuality is a sin because it does not produce children. I agree: that line of reasoning doesn't hold up.
But that's not the only conceivable (no pun intended) reason why the Bible would say that homosexuality is a sin.
The easiest answer would be to say, "it just is, just ...
8
I think this has to do with whether biblical laws should apply to non-Christians or not.
1 Corinthians 5:12-13 (ESV)
12 For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Is it not those inside the church whom you are to judge? 13 God judges those outside. "Purge the evil person from among you."
So, we should not seek to judge outsiders. Not even by ...
8
From canonical Scripture alone, I don't think that argument could be made.
The mosaic law clearly forbids homosexuality in Leviticus 18:22, making it a sin in God's eyes. If Jeus came, and fulfilled the law, which he said he did, in Matthew 5:17-18, then that would have to mean that he followed the entirety of the law to the letter, including the ...
7
If Jesus did not in fact say that, it doesn't mean that Paul and Christ are in contradiction with one another. Not saying something does not mean acceptance or approval.
That said, Jesus has made a stand and voiced opposition against homosexuality. Just not while He was performing his ministry here on earth.
First, Jesus is God: John 8:58 - Jesus said to ...
7
I'm pretty sure this has been covered here before but...
The problematic interpretation here is not the second of the two you mention it us the first. Neither passage is a teaching passage about what is right or wrong expression of sexuality. Both passages are narrative of events that happened and both events are condemned.
The Genesis passage is not a ...
7
To directly answer the question:
The key claim here tends to be the assertion that Christianity (via Judaism) defines marriage (itself a tenuous claim, with polygamy being common, and no formal final definition) and pre-dates civil institutions (claimed since if you use the Biblical account, marriage goes right back to genesis, therefore to the start). And ...
6
You're not going to like this answer, but that's because I think the premise is flawed. Why is homosexuality given a standing all its own? What's wrong with the other hundreds of works and confessions by Reformed thinkers regarding sin?
The question is not one of legality, but one of morality. Speaking from a Reformed Baptist perspective (I know, not truly ...
6
Quite simply, no, it's not fair to say that. I do not know Hebrews, but I do know that in Greek, the word anthropos indicates a generic man or person, while aner means specifically a person who is male. If we went through the entire Bible and applied an exclusive gender wherever it said "man", it would be nonsensical.
Whoever sheds the blood of man, by ...
5
I don't know anyone who says that he believes homosexual marriage is bad but homosexual sex in general is okay. The nature of the current legal debate is that homosexuals are demanding a change in the laws regarding marriage, which some who believe homosexuality to be a sin are opposing. If I understand you correctly, you are saying that you see an ...
5
Good question.
The question really asks to what degree should government impose the truth on the world. The Bible does condemn homosexuality but it does not in my view villianize the homosexual beyond the sins of any regular sinner, in which it accuses everyone. I say this because I do not think it s Biblical for homosexuals to feel more sinful than ...
5
You could make a Biblical argument for Jesus being asexual and showing affection (but not sexual desire) to both genders. John 13:25 Luke 7:44
It's not possible to make a Biblical argument for him expressing either heterosexuality or homosexuality. It would have been perfectly acceptable for Jesus to be married and have children under Jewish and Christian ...
5
The main argument is based not just on a dubious manuscript, but on a dubious interpretation of that manuscript.
The Mar Saba Letter
In 1958, Morton Smith—a history professor at Columbia University—was looking through documents in the monastery of Mar Saba when he found (he claims) a letter written by second century theologian Clement of ...
4
If you refer to a legal Christian justification?
None.
Oh, There is the Bible stance, that's well known and documented here, I don't need to repeat it. There is the personal moral view, that's all over this topic, no need to revisit it.
I do see a general "fear" in the answers, ~"If people perform homosexual acts, God's gonna punish us all." ...
4
Many people like to have some kind of sin not categorized as sin. This question about Homosexuality is repeatedly asked by many, But bible clearly says that Homosexulal or Men having sex with Men will not enter in to the Kingdom of God. I also do not understand why no one refers to this passage written by Paul, which gives maximum clarity
Read 1 ...
4
The Basis of Love
This is an interesting question. You are correct in that we as Christians are commanded to love. This was modeled for us by Jesus, who loved the world, forgave those who called for His crucifixion, washed the feet of His disciples, touched the leper, removed people's shame, and set people free.
Homosexuality and Sin
I understand that ...
4
Jesus says "Blessed (happy, but not in the common sense) are you when they utter all sorts of things falsely because of me. "
If this fellow persisted in when he ardently thought was right, just and beneficial for his fellow man, there is no real reason for him to stop just because he is being jeered at.
However, if his words come not from love of others ...
4
You are nearly right that an important Christian ideal is love, actually it is the ideal:
Hearing that Jesus had silenced the Sadducees, the Pharisees got together. 35 One of them, an expert in the law, tested him with this question: “Teacher, which is the greatest commandment in the Law?”
Jesus replied: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart ...
4
I think that the easiest answer is that homosexuality is "unnatural" (cf. Romans 1). Now, before someone tries to correct me and say, "it happens in nature all the time," I am not talking about "nature" in the same sense you might turn on the Discovery Channel and watch flying shark vs flying crocodile. After all, rape is something which is found in a number ...
3
I look at it from a different point-of-view. Should another religious group, perhaps animists, or we could go with a non-religious group such as vegans, push their views, if they had the majority? So, if the majority of those in power were vegans, and they passed a law banning any meat or products from animals not willingly given (so honey for example ...
Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible


