Take the 2-minute tour ×
Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Or why do people here always ask "What does the Bible say?"... why not ask the proper "What does God say?".

share|improve this question
2  
Let's see... What does Wikipedia say on this subject? –  ℝaphink Aug 29 '11 at 14:42
    
Raphink, I doubt there is an article on the subject. Are you being sarcastic? –  dleyva3 Aug 29 '11 at 16:00
3  
With all the answers given you would think there was a bounty on this. –  JustinY Aug 29 '11 at 18:02
    
When I read the question title in the list I thought, "seriously?", but reading the question, it's actually quite a good one. –  Lawrence Dol Aug 29 '11 at 19:08
    
@JustinY: funny. :D On a serious note: I think it's because the Bible is such an important, nay, crucial part of Christianity. It's our holy book. Yup, even mine ;-) As such, the way we see/read the bible is so fundemental to our understanding of what "being a Christian" mean, what "being us" means. It brings together and sets apart. And it's core to our very own personal (and often private) belief and being. Woah... –  Jürgen A. Erhard Aug 29 '11 at 19:31
show 1 more comment

8 Answers

up vote 12 down vote accepted

I hope it's obvious that the Bible (a book) and God (a divine being) are not the same thing. It has never been part of Christian theology that the Bible should be worshipped, or that believing the Bible is synonymous with Christianity. The Bible as we know it today did not exist at all for many decades after Jesus' death, and in its present form for hundreds of years, yet Christians certainly existed during that time. Almost all Christians take the Bible as a true and infallible word from God. But views on other communication from God differ. One area of difference is in Jesus statements about what is to happen after his death. He never states that his followers are to use the scriptures only, but "I will be with you" and "My spirit I give to you". Interpretations of that differ.

One view is that the scriptures are foundational, but the Spirit gives additional revelation to Christians. In the Catholic view, the Spirit does this through the Church, specifically the church leadership. In other traditions this can happen through the church in community: in still others, to individual people. In either case revelations though the Spirit cannot contradict the Scriptures, but they can add to them. Some denominations believe in the office of "a prophet", who can convey commands from God for a specific time and place. Except for in some small denominations, and some specific cases in Catholicism, post-biblical revelations are not given the same 'infallibility' status that the Bible has.

In another view the presence of the Spirit to guide the followers of Jesus like this only lasted for the Apostolic Age, and was replaced by the Bible. This is the view of much non-Charismatic Protestantism. For those people the question "what does God say" and "what does the Bible say" are essentially synonymous.

However even the most ardent believer in a solely biblical authority will usually allow for the idea of personal guidance - i.e. that a person can pray to God and ask what to do in their specific circumstances, and receive an answer. In this case that is "what God says" to them. However what God says to one person doesn't necessarily apply to another.

share|improve this answer
add comment

By asking what the Bible says, you know what you get.

If you ask what God says, you hear what

  • the Bible says
  • the Pope says
  • a prophet I know says
  • a lunatic thinking they're God says
  • the Qur'an says

You get the idea.

share|improve this answer
    
+1 nice and succinct. Wish I could upvote more than once. –  Bob Black Sep 7 '11 at 14:08
    
I get your idea, but I disagree. You basically say that, if I ask what God says, I don't hear what he says. I think you can. Not that you automatically do... it's easier to pick up the Bible and read, certainly, than to learn "to know his voice" or, worse, wait for the Spirit to answer. 's why the Bible has the position it has: it's there when I want it. The Spirit isn't. Not when I want, anyway. –  Jürgen A. Erhard Sep 20 '11 at 14:55
    
@JürgenA.Erhard I mean if you ask other people what the Bible says vs. what God says. –  dancek Sep 20 '11 at 15:26
1  
I wish it was as simple as "if you ask what the Bible says, you know what you get". The wildly different opinions on what the Bible says are contrary evidence. –  DJClayworth Sep 11 '13 at 17:46
add comment

The Bible is not God, but God breathed and God sustained.

People are asking, "What does the Bible say", because the underlying understanding is that we all know the Bible is real. However, the secular people visiting this website would/will argue the existence of God but not the existence of the Bible.

Some people also take the Bible to be different levels of true. Some, like myself, believe that God said everything in the Bible, others don't believe that the bible is God speaking the whole time.

This it is appropriate to just ask, "what does the Bible say".

share|improve this answer
add comment

It's arguable that one could say "What does the bible say?" and "What does God say?" are interchangeable since the Bible was inspired by the Holy Spirit, and is called by many the "Written word of God". By saying "What does the Bible say?" we provide a common point of reference between individuals who might hear from God differently or even interpret what He says differently.

share|improve this answer
1  
"the Bible was inspired by the Holy Spirit": true. "the two are interchangeable". No, absolutely not. If you are worshipping the Bible you are in real trouble, and if you are doing NOTHING except following the Bible then you are neglecting very important teaching. –  DJClayworth Aug 29 '11 at 16:23
    
Sorry I should have been more clear, saying "What does the Bible say?" and "What does God say?" are interchangeable. I agree you should not worship the bible nor neglect the other aspects of our faith. –  Andrew Aug 29 '11 at 16:33
    
Much clearer. I removed the downvote. –  DJClayworth Aug 29 '11 at 16:59
add comment

The two are not the same, but we often ask "What does the Bible say", because we believe it's the best source for God's intentions.

The Reformed tradition even goes so far as to have Sola Scriptura as a core tenet. This basically means that they believe that everything God thought we needed to know is available in the Bible, and no further writings are necessary to live a Christian life (though obviously they see it as beneficial, as the Reformed churches publish a lot of books).

Other traditions may treat the Bible as less central, but it's still a core part of Christian belief.

share|improve this answer
add comment

While one is a book full of words and one is a divine being (and thus are in no way the same thing), Christians believe the Bible to be God's inspired word. Thus asking "What does the Bible say about x?" is approximately the same thing as asking, "What does God say about x"? The Bible is the written record we have of God's proclamations to men, and the primary way we know who He is and what He stands for.

share|improve this answer
add comment

The Bible is an anthology of books inspired by the Holy Spirit.

God's Word (Gn 1, Jn 1) is the second person of the Trinity.

God is His Word (Jesus). God's words are not His written words, but they ideas they express.

Unlike in Harry Potter 2, if you write a book, it doesn't become you. If you write a book you stay you, your thoughts go into the book but remain with you.

God's Word is His thought (Jesus) and the act of thinking that thought is the Holy Spirit (Their mutual love). You can't separate any of this from the one Divine Entity.

share|improve this answer
add comment

I'm not sure that I would have any general qualms about using the phrasings interchangably, but they do have the potential to give different connotations with regard to the mode through which a person is seeking his answers. This points to the distinction between revelation, inspiration, and illumination. (FTR, I'm not endorsing all of the implications put forth in that link, but it does do a good job summarizing the differences between the three modes of communication).

From the link:

Revelation: From God to man (man hears what God wants written)

Inspiration: From man to paper (man writes that which God wants written)

Illumination: From paper to heart (man receives that which God has written)

When we (directly) look to "what the Bible says" in order to (indirectly) discern "what God says," we're trusting in the inspiration of the biblical authors and illumination of the Spirit to "shed light on" those words of Scripture which have been revealed to those authors and offered to all men. If someone uses the phrase they're looking to "what God says," it can be ambiguous as to what exactly they mean (are they appealing to a "special revelation" of visions and prophecies that they alone are privvy to?)

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.