Take the 2-minute tour ×
Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This is a simple historical Q & A question regarding the rumor that Luther made this fairly inflammatory accusation.  The question is simple. Is there any solid proof that Luther really thought this and made this incredible accusation?

Is it true that Luther claimed Popes and priests commonly practiced sodomy?

share|improve this question
1  
This has to do with Christianity the religion? Or is it the history of a popular Christian? –  user1054 Sep 14 '12 at 17:46
4  
@Dan General info about figures in Christian history are on topic, and certainly anything said by a major theologian is fair game. You could argue this is a bad question, but not on that basis. –  Caleb Sep 15 '12 at 1:44
3  
Mike, I agree with you on a lot of things, but it seems to me that your recent questions are specifically meant to be jabs at Catholicism. I fail to see how this is relevant, and can do anything other than to insult Catholics. I don't know if it's intentional or not, but really, that's not constructive. Whether we agree with each other on all (or any) points, there's an expectation of mutual respect here. I'm voting to close on those grounds. –  David Stratton Sep 15 '12 at 5:11
2  
@DavidStratton - The problem is there is actually no logical reason to close this question, therefore, no way to re-open it if closed. What this is tying to do is simply unashamed censorship. You have made your reason the emotionally based and personal, but I am merely studying the reformation right now so have posted a series on the facts surrounding the case. –  Mike Sep 15 '12 at 6:35
2  
@David in all honesty, I can't think of a way this question is not relevant. If this was truly off-topic, then an awful lot of history / background questions must also be deemed off-topic. It is not right to close it just because it is embarrassing / inconvenient to any particular denomination. –  Marc Gravell Sep 15 '12 at 7:01
show 3 more comments

1 Answer 1

up vote 7 down vote accepted

Actually, surprisingly,  Luther did think this and did make this accusation.  Luther made John the Baptist's accusation against Herod's adultery seem trivial compared to the corruption of the Roman clergy. Clearly he accused the Roman clergy of practicing sodomy:

I am not lying to you. Whoever has been in Rome knows that conditions are unfortunately worse there than anyone can say or believe. When the last Lateran council was to be concluded in Rome under Pope Leo, among other articles it was decreed that one must believe the soul to be immortal. From this one may gather that they make eternal life an object of sheer mockery and contempt. In this way they confess that it is a common belief among them that there is no eternal life, but that they now wish to proclaim this by means of a bull. More remarkable yet, in the same bull they decided that a cardinal should not keep as many boys in the future. However, Pope Leo commanded that this be deleted; otherwise it would have been spread throughout the whole world how openly and shamelessly the pope and the cardinals in Rome practice sodomy. I do not wish to mention the pope, but since the knaves will not repent, but condemn the gospel, blaspheme and revile God’s word, and excuse their vices, they, in turn, will have to take a whiff of their own terrible filth. This vice is so prevalent among them that recently a pope caused his own death by means of this sin and vice.In fact, he died on the spot. All right now, you popes, cardinals, papists, spiritual lords, keep on persecuting God’s word and defending your doctrine and your churches!

No pope, cardinal, bishop, doctor, priest, monk, or nun will condemn such an obviously disgraceful life; rather they laugh about it, excuse it, and gloss over it. They incite kings, princes, country, and people to defend such knaves with life and property, with land and people, and faithfully to protect them so that such vices might not be repented of and reformed, but rather strengthened, sanctioned, and approved. Now you are to hazard blood, body, and life just for the sake of Saddling your neck and conscience with this. I could easily mention more examples of such abominations, but it is too shameful; I fear that our German soil would have to tremble before it. But if an impudent popish ass should come along and dispute this, he will find me ready to do him battle, and it will be quite a battle!  (Luther's Works Volume 47, P38)

It appears that he thought this practice was related to the forced abstinence that the priests and Pope had to bear:

There Is Danger in Avoiding Marriage May 29, 1539 Thereupon there was conversation about the delightful institution of marriage. [Martin Luther said,] “Through the papists Satan so defiled it that in his little book on the celibacy of priests Cyprian wrote, ‘If you hear a woman speak, flee from her as if she were a hissing snake.’ That’s the way it is. When one is afraid of whores one must fall into Sodomite depravity, as almost happened to St. Jerome.   ( Luther's Works Volume 54, P357)

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.