Sign up ×
Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Recently, I had the chance to visit the birthplace of Mormonism (Hill Cumorah / Palmayra, NY), and learn the origin of the LDS Scriptures. In particular, I became quite interested in the Three Witnesses - Harris, Whitemer, and Cowdery. From the stories I read, these three seem instrumental in the translation / dictation of the original vision, and even in the early formation of the church in April, 1830.

And yet, none of them ever seems to have been prominent in the church since then. I understand that all three left the church (though two returned), and so I can understand why they never became President - but there seems to be a gap in the record for me as to where Brigham Young came from.

When did he enter the Mormon story? Why was he sufficiently credible to be able to lead the bulk of the church to Utah? What specifically was the "torch-passing" if you will that led Brigham Young to be considered Smith's successor?

share|improve this question
Hehe, I think Joseph Smith is even more well known leader than Brigham was! That said, Brigham Young was quite the character! Did you know that he didn't like reading and writing so he invented a new phonetic alphabet? Hilarious Quirks aside, we can thank him for the settlement of almost the entire western united states. – Eric Jun 11 '13 at 17:41

2 Answers 2

up vote 13 down vote accepted

The reason behind Young's rise to prominence is found in an understanding of the organization known as the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles and Young's role in it.

Young joined the church in 1832, 2 years after the church was organized and after the publication of the Book of Mormon, therefore he had no part in the initial roots of Mormonism. In 1834, Joseph Smith organized Zion's camp in Ohio as a military expedition to Missouri in order to fight persecution that the Mormons received there. The camp never actually engaged in any fighting, however there were many who defected and it allowed Smith to gauge who would be loyal to him even in hardship. Brigham Young was a member of this camp.

In 1835 after the return of the expedition, Smith then organized the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles. Most of the members of the the quorum were selected from those who were loyal in Zion's camp. Brigham Young was one of the first ordained and set apart to the quorum but did not have the designation of senior most apostle. As you mentioned many people were excommunicated from the church in those days. Though most of the quorum remained faithful, a few were excommunicated or killed, necessitating calling more people to the quorum. Young quickly became the senior most apostle of the quorum of the twelve. Thomas B. Marsh, who happened to be in the first presidency, was the senior most apostle before his excommunication in 1839. Young was subsequently set apart as president of the quorum in 1840 as a result of his new status as senior most apostle. He held this designation until Smith's death.

Brigham Young was not considered the second-in-charge to Smith. That was given to Smith's brother Hyrum who was ordained "Assistant to the President of the Church". Following him, the other natural successors would seemingly be the members of the first presidency. Hyrum was killed along with Joseph, ruling out Hyrum's succession. The subsequent succession crisis ensued; would it be the senior most member of the first presidency, would it be the senior most member of the quorum of the twelve apostles, or was it to be Smith's posterity?

Several candidates for Smith's succession emerged, and all of them gained some followers. Young contended, using revelations recorded by Smith, that the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles as a body held all the 'keys' of the priesthood that Smith held, and that the first presidency was dissolved upon Smith's death, and that the Quorum held authority equal to that of the first presidency. He was successful in convincing many of his rightful succession. Sidney Rigdon, Young's primary challenger, proposed that Smith have no successor and that he be named "guardian" of the church. The majority of church members rejected that motion. A few others believed that Smith's successor was to be Joseph Smith III (who was not even an adolescent at the time).

Young's personality was forceful, charismatic, and direct. His ability for quick decision making and well-articulated instruction allowed him to emerge as a natural leader following Smith's death. He organized the very difficult colonization of the Rocky Mountains: Utah, Idaho, Nevada, Arizona, and others; he led the church through federal persecution for polygamous practices; he helped organize the difficult immigration of European Mormon converts to Utah. Under his leadership, vast irrigation projects, roads, bridges and even universities were established in Utah and surrounding areas. There is little doubt that he had the credentials to lead the church at that time. Young led the church for a time merely as president of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles. Most of the extant Quorum of the Twelve Apostles followed him and, with the belief that as a body they had the same authority as Joseph Smith, they eventually ordained Young as Smith's successor in 1847, giving him the same power, authority, and title that Joseph Smith had in the church.

Today, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which is the largest LDS denomination and is headquartered in Utah, still follows the same succession practice. When the president of the church dies, the first presidency is dissolved and the senior most apostle is ordained to the office of "Prophet, Seer, and Revelator." It is believed that the current president has the same power and authority that Joseph Smith had.

For more information from official sources, see:,_Brigham

Additionally, the Wikipedia articles covering these subjects, though somewhat disorganized, appear to be relatively accurate and present several other views.

share|improve this answer
Wow! Exhaustive and illuminating! Thank you! – Affable Geek Aug 20 '12 at 11:13

There is some thought he may have conspired in the deaths of some potential rivals for Mormon leadership after smith and his brother were killed and was able to take control of the enterprise that way

This information can be found in a book, the Mormon Hierachy, by D. Michael Quinn, a respected historian and former professor, by the way, at BYU.

Samuel Smith, younger brother of Joseph, died about a month after Joe. He, on his death bed as a man in his mid 30's, and his family, claimed his poisoning. His uncle likewise was administered medications but quit their administration without informing anyone and thus credited that to his survival. Bringham Young maintained his innocence claiming his absence out of town. See his (Young's) talk as recorded July 1857, Journal of Discourses Vol 5 p77. I would suggest interested souls read the book for deeper and more complete information, including information regarding a Mr. Hosea Stout and his dealings with Bringham Young.

The speculation is that the motive was to prevent the younger Smith from ascending to the presidency and to allow the pro polygamy faction to take over. The brother Smith was anti-poligamy and had strong support. In the least, Here was a lot of worldly power and attractive forms at stake

share|improve this answer
Welcome to the site. This answer would be a lot better if you added specifics as well as references. Right now it's innuendo, which in an academic context is not ideal, especially when dealing with a sensitive subject (such as accusing one of the founders of a major religion of murder). See How we are different than other sites? and What makes a good supported answer? – Bear in a Studebaker Jan 3 at 19:12
If you are accusing me of accusing young, why sir I never did such a thing. I have read of speculation regarding sudden deaths of rivals who were poisoned or at least their families thought so and one gave a death bed claim to such and one instance of a rival who survived, giving credit of his surviving to his stopping taking the powdered medication given him by a mormon doctor.Young himself denied involvement in these matters using his being out of town at the time as an alibi. – Ya lo creo Jan 3 at 20:33
So give us references for such deaths, as in who and when. Also references for how exactly those deaths helped propel him toward leadership. That's what makes for a good supported answer on this site. – Bear in a Studebaker Jan 3 at 20:35
The book The Mormon Hierarchy by D. Michael Quinn, pgs 152-153 Bringham young himself defended himself on these charges in a talk I think in 1857, the death was Samuel Smith, young brother of Joseph and his uncle was the man who quit the medication and thus survived. The when was about a month after Joseph's death and the where was Navoo – Ya lo creo Jan 3 at 20:49
Please edit that into your answer along with relevant quotes. – Bear in a Studebaker Jan 3 at 20:53

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.