Tell me more ×
Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Why do people often seem to give credit to their God instead of themselves or those directly deserved of the credit?

For example, the food you eat likely came from a farm or store, why not thank the farmers or the store owners and employees instead?

Or another example, if a student does well on a test and exclaims "thank God I got did well on that test," they are depriving themself of credit they earned. By doing so, their confidence could ultimately suffer. They took the initiative to study for the test instead of watching TV. They paid attention in class and took notes. And ultimately, they took the test and answered the questions correctly.

Why don't people seem to give their self or those involved credit more often?

share|improve this question
2  
Everybody with any awareness knows that the results of the test, or of the football game, are not entirely under their control. To some degree results are always going to be dependent on God, if you believe in him, or luck if you don't. Likewise how do you think you acquired the intelligence and determination to study successfully? Most of those abilities weren't decided by you. – DJClayworth Jan 11 '12 at 14:32
@DJClayworth, I don't mean to cause an argument I am genuinely interested in an answer to this question. The whole purpose of my asking is to avoid comments or answers such as "to some degree results are always going to be dependent on God." I expect that type of thought here but I'm asking why is that the case? – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 15:25
1  
Your question just doesn’t make any sense. If you don’t believe that there is a god then perhaps you should be asking “Why thank a god that isn’t there?” If you do, the farms that give you food exist on a planet that came from him. And in that way we do give credit where it rightly belongs. – Monika Michael Jul 4 '12 at 15:36

4 Answers

There is a distinction between stewardship and provision. Christians who thank God for all things realize that it is God who gives us life, who gave us our minds to understand, our talents and skills with which we labor, our ability to learn and think, our health, who blesses the work of our hands and our relationships with others, who has enabled us to have a house, who created all the food we enjoy and are able to cultivate on this earth, who gave us the earth on which to live, and a hundred other things. Praying before meals is simply a daily reminder to us of God's continued provision in all things.

You are right that we have taken the initiative to study and learn, but God gave us our minds to understand and blessed us with the opportunity to learn and to live in a country where that is even possible and where we can worship God freely.

This, however, is all stewardship. God has given us all these things, and it is our responsibility and privilege to use our talents, skills, abilities, and opportunities wisely. So, when we do this, it is commendable. Yet, it is nothing compared to all that God has given us.

To glory more in what we have done with what God has given us than in the God who gives is inappropriate. That's like taking credit for drinking milk as a baby. It's your mom who gives it to you--you are just the recipient.

share|improve this answer
Thank you for your answer. It seems that my type of question is not really welcome here, I thought the idea was to learn and expand. I don't consider "because God said so" (or similar) to be a concise answer - this is just a blanket statement that could be applied to anything. I wanted people to dig deeper and really give an honest answer as to why [Christian] society behaves this way. Instead of defaulting to the expected "because of God" response. – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 15:30
@JoshM. It's important to try not to sound argumentative or abrasive. I, as a committed believer, try to assume the best of the questioner, believing that there are sound answers for all questions related to Christianity. I thought this was a valid question. This made me think of the old movie, "Shenandoah", where Jimmy Stewart prays such a prayer: blog.founders.org/2010/11/… – Narnian Jan 11 '12 at 15:58
I hadn't seen that clip before but yes, that's what I'm getting at, for the most part. It wasn't supposed to come off as abrasive, but I think any other way this was stated probably still would have seemed like an abrasive attack - again, that wasn't the intention. It's hard to question something that isn't meant to be questioned, I suppose. – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 16:50
@JoshM: I think your question is a good one, but it presupposes the answer that God does not deserve the credit. I think that's why it sounds argumentative/abrasive. But it's also easy to see why one would word the question that way, when asking from a non-Christian viewpoint. – Flimzy Jan 11 '12 at 22:52

Quite simply, we do give credit where credit is due.

As a Christian I am quite happy to thank the farmer for their labors or the waitress for serving me, but I believe that it is God who provides me the food (and the farmer rain and the waitress a job).

The same reasoning can be applied to all your other cases. The example of "self" however is most out of place with Christian belief. We don't pat ourselves on the back or boast in our accomplishments because we know that any talent or ability we posses or any success our labors is a grace from God, of which we are only stewards.

share|improve this answer
1  
Your last sentence is the exact point I'm getting at. You've stated it perfectly. You (as in Christians, not just you personally) attribute all positive outcomes to God instead of giving yourself credit when (I believe) it's due. I can't wrap my head around this type of thinking and hence, I asked the question. – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 16:52
3  
@JoshM. Your postulate that you are due any credit is based on a worldview that says you are somehow autonomous and belong to yourself. Christianity understands the world and it's inhabitants to be creatures made by the hand of a creator for His own glory -- hence belonging to him. Further Christians believe that although they rebelled against that creator, the same God bought them back with a price. That makes us doubly in His service if such a thing were possible. Being stewards of anything is more than we deserve, hence the thanks (to the one due). – Caleb Jan 11 '12 at 17:17
This is a very sad, depressing point of view in my opinion. We deserve everything we receive so long as we are "good people." I don't live for God because I am indebted to him or her. I live because I'm alive and have the ability to decide on my own how I should behave, what I should do and how I should treat others. Therefore, since I put effort into my daily life, I think I'm due credit when I've accomplished something - that doesn't seem too crazy to me. – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 18:54
@JoshM. Aaa, but that's just the crux of the matter. We're not "good people". And it's not sad or depressing at all, it's the gladdest news I could imagine. You have to get the whole picture. Chemo therapy sounds like a nasty medicine until you discover there is a kind that is a 100% certain cure for the terminal cancer you were just diagnosed with. – Caleb Jan 11 '12 at 19:12
5  
Very nice answer! And @Josh M, I don't think it's sad at all. I think that it's good, in a world full of boastful people and a society so focused on self, to truly give credit to the One who gave us the abilities. I'm a self-taught computer programmer doing my hobby for a living. I could brag about that, or I could be thankful, grateful, and in awe of a God that could instill in me the desire and ability to do something that not only brings me joy, but pays well. Plus He gave me a wonderful wife, great kids... It makes me happy to give Him credit and be thankful rather than prideful. – David Stratton Jan 12 '12 at 3:30
show 3 more comments

the food you eat likely came from a farm or store, why not thank the farmers ?

Who created the the soil, the seeds, provided the rain? Who created the farmer?

if a student does well on a test and exclaims "thank God I got did well on that test,"

Who gifted the student with the motivation to study and the strength of mind to store and recall what he studied at the exam time (hint: it wasn't just his parents).

share|improve this answer
1) The big bang; evolution. 2) Parents; up-bringing; society; internal desire to succeed. -- You can't just blindly say that all of that is because of God, which is what you're implying, right? – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 18:50
3  
@Josh - the question is asked out of the christian world view, which may allow for the Big Bang, but even presumes that God is still behind even that. – Joel Coehoorn Jan 11 '12 at 20:39
I asked the question; it wasn't out of the Christian point of view, it was out of a non-denominational view. Thanks. – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 23:21
"out of" was perhaps the wrong preposition, but if you're asking a question at a site about Christianity, you should expect the response to come from that world view. – Joel Coehoorn Jan 13 '12 at 6:10

I believe we thank God for the condition for all these things and not for a specific thing.

One day at church the pastor said that we should thank God for every good thing that happen to us and blame ourselves for every bad thing that happen, to me that is stupid.

I'm used to say that God gave man two powers, the one to create and the other to destroy in any aspect, you choose what to do according to His words.

We are responsible for what we do, not God.

There are some other things we like to put God in the middle. There are who say that God is in control of everything and not even a leaf will fall from the tree without his order.

I don't really think that God, the creator of everything we know, see and feel, is worried about a leaf falling or not falling from a tree. I believe that He have created 3 laws. The Biological, Physical and Moral laws.

It doesn't matter who or what you are, one day you will die and get sick. (Biological Law)

It doesn't matter who or what you are, you will fall if you jump. (Physical Law)

It doesn't matter who or what you are, if you cheat, kill, disobey, etc, it will be seen as a wrong attitude. (Moral Law)

PS: Sorry for my poor english =)

share|improve this answer
Well put and I appreciate your view. Your English is fine! – Josh M. Jan 11 '12 at 18:51
@JoshM. double thanks =] – Gerep Jan 11 '12 at 19:03
This represents a Deist world view, not a Christian one. This site is supposed to be Questions and Answers about Christianity. Please cite references for what Christian group believes God doesn't care about the details. – Caleb Jan 11 '12 at 19:15
1  
@Caleb no, it is my point o view and it is not Deist, it is Christian, if what I'm saying is not a true Christian point, prove I'm wrong according to Bible, with all the respect – Gerep Jan 11 '12 at 19:19

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.