Take the 2-minute tour ×
Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Catholic doctrines of Penance teach that if a priest forgives the sin of a parishioner, then that sin is forgiven by God as well- the sacrament of Penance is effective, and not just ceremonial. Likewise, the doctrines on excommunication from the church say that if a person is damned by the church, the anathema is effective. A common phrase in the Gopels (cf. John 20, Mark 18) is What is loosed is loosed, and what is bound is bound.

What denominations or Christian groups other than the Roman Catholic Church teach specifically that a Christian can or cannot forgive the sins of another person?

If a particular denomination teaches that they can do, do the doctrines of the denomination distinguish between the members of the Church that are able to perform this ministry and those that are not?

share|improve this question
    
Seeing as how this question has a lot of back story, I recommend fully expanding on your thoughts that came from those comments. I know what you are asking, because I was there as the comments were being written, but reading this question as is, I don't think you have used enough words to make the question known. –  fredsbend Jun 24 at 21:52
3  
I don't believe any Christian denominations believe humans can forgive sins; some may believe humans can declare them forgiven, at which time God forgives them. But the Bible makes it pretty clear that only God can forgive sins. –  Flimzy Jun 24 at 22:33
    
Anyone can of course forgive someone for the sins committed against them, but that's a different sense than God forgiving and taking away the guilt of sin. Which sense do you mean? –  curiousdannii Jun 24 at 23:41
    
@Flimzy Where in the Bible does it say that? –  Andrew Jun 25 at 1:45
3  
This question should be placed on-hold because it needs a bit of work to clarify what is being asked and also needs to rephrase parts that appear to be asking what is "True" instead of what is believed by certain Christians (ie the title says "Do Christians have the authority to forgive sins". Having your question put on-hold is not permanent; it will be reversed when the issues are resolved. –  fredsbend Jun 25 at 7:04

3 Answers 3

I would say to a degree all should (as @curiousdannii said). Take John 20:22-24 into account for this,

If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld.

I believe what you are asking is more directed to the Office of the Keys as Lutheran's call it (which is more known in Catholicism as Confession/Absolution/Penance). This is not to be confused as a Christian absolving another of sins against others, but an affirmation that with your confession, God hears it, and the Christian conveys that reassurance based on the Gospel (1 John 1:9). Obviously few denominations practice (liturgical ones in addition to Catholicism, like Anglican, Methodist, Orthodox, Lutheran).

share|improve this answer
    
Christians in my non-denominational tradition do something similar. It is common to confess to a trusted friend or small group of friends regularly. There is an idea of 'accountability' between Christians. –  Andrew Jun 25 at 1:17
    
Can you provide any links to Lutheran sources that discuss the "Office of the Keys"? I know of some documents that define the Catholic sacrament of Penance. –  Andrew Jun 25 at 1:43
    
@Andrew, there are several sections in the Book of Concord. Namely, bookofconcord.org/augsburgconfession.php#article25 and bookofconcord.org/smalcald.php#keys and Luther's Small Catechism where he writes, "Confession embraces two parts: the one is, that we confess our sins; the other, that we receive absolution, or forgiveness, from the confessor, as from God Himself, and in no wise doubt, but firmly believe, that our sins are thereby forgiven before God in heaven." –  Aibrean Jun 25 at 2:08
    
I assume confessor here is the person receiving the confession? –  Andrew Jun 25 at 2:48

The sacrament of confession (or penance or reconcilliation) was not specifically instituted by any of the Gospels. However, all four Gospels address the forgiveness of sin and the sacrament is entirely consistent with what Jesus is purported to have said and done. This is evidenced not only by John 20:22-23, but on the other Gospel accounts of Jesus forgiving sins as an inherent component of the act of healing (Matt 9:2-8; Mark 2:5-12; and Luke 5:20-26).

Early New Testament churches were more focused on compassion, correction, and forgiveness. Mutual correction and forgiveness were part of the fabric of community life. Compassion was balanced with the understanding of the impact of sin upon the communal life and mission of the church. At times, a form of excommunication (1 Cor 5: 3-5; 1 Tim 1: 19-20) was exercised for the good of the church.

Over time, the sacrament of confession changed as the church spread to different cultures and societies. At times, Confession was a sacrament that was to be administered only once during an individual's lifetime. This administration usually was for the forgiveness of particularly onerous offenses such as apostasy, murder of adultery or upon the deathbed of the individual. The sacrament usually required demonstrable proof of repentance and often included a vow of celibacy from that point forward. For this reason, many individuals delayed the sacrament until they were close to death. A penitent (person requesting forgiveness) would be excluded from receiving the Eucharist and would be excused from the celebration at the offertory along with the catechumens.

As the needs of the people and the circumstances of the Church changed, private penance became the norm. By the end of the 6th century, "penance" became known as "confession." The once in a lifetime public rite of penance ended in the Western Church with the Fourth Council of Lateran's decree in 1215 that all baptized Christians must confess their sins and receive Holy Eucharist at least once each year.

The sacrament was influenced over the intervening centuries by many factors. The influence of the Celtic churches was significant. The monastic nature of the Celtic Churches brought the sacrament into a more private environment. In effect, the sacrament was taken out of the church as a whole and into the private chambers of the penitent and his/her confessor (the person hearing the confession). This Celtic influence extended the confessor relationship to priests as well as bishops who had that role exclusively exclusively.

From the eleventh to the fourteenth centuries, major changes occurred in the sacrament of penance. Penance became the satisfaction, confession, contrition and absolution of sins. The emphasis had shifted from the reconciliation of the sinner with the Church (and with God) to doing 'penance.' Also, the act of confession was deemed to have redemptive value in the life of the penitent. That redemptive value also assisted in converting the heart of the sinner, who if truly contrite, was already forgiven even before the act of confession. This aspect contributed to Albigensian and Waldensian heresies that denied the need to confess to a priest. These heresies were condemned by the Fourth Lateran Council as well. The role of the priest was then reinforced and the element of absolution was added to the sacrament.

St. Thomas Acquinas had a great influence on the sacrament and his views were incorporated into the Council of Florence decree for the Armenians in 1439. This document stated that Penance is a sacrament; it consists of contrition of the heart; oral confession to a priest; satisfaction (such as prayer, almsgiving, fasting, etc...); and absolution by the priest. The end result of the sacrament is the forgiveness of sins.

During the Reformation, there were some objections to this formula. Luther accepted Penance as a sacrament, but rejected the aspect that an individual's works were in any way more important than God's Mercy. He also rejected that the power of forgiveness was limited to priests. Calvin accepted private confession and absolution as a means of arousing faith and the recognition of God's Mercy but rejected it as a sacrament. These arguments were addressed by the Council of Trent in 1551. In the Doctrine on the Sacrament of Penance, the following teachings were affirmed: Penance is a sacrament instituted by Christ; it is distinct from Baptism; the three acts of the penitent are contrition, confession of all serious sins and satisfaction; and absolution is reserved to priests alone.

As a result of Vatican II, there has been a revision to the Rite and nature of the sacrament. The purpose of these revisions is to express both the nature and the effect of the sacrament. The purpose is to "obtain pardon from the mercy of God: and to be "reconciled with the Church whom sinners have wounded by their sin." The new Rite of Penance is frequently referred to as the sacrament of Reconciliation. That name more accurately reflects the intended purpose of the sacrament. It takes the focus off the acts of restitution and places it more on the restoration of the individual to the body of Christ, His Church.

There are four forms in the new rite. They are indidual, communal with individual confession and absolution, communal with general absolution and an abbreviated ritual in cases where death is near. The new rite clearly shows the nature and effect of the sacramen; the role of the church community; an emphasis on the reading of God's Word; a shift of emphasis to the public and away from the private forms; and simplicity.

Finally, a thought about the role of the priest in the Sacrament of Penance and Reconciliation. In the Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 1441 states, "Only God forgives sins. Since he is the Son of God, Jesus says of himself, “The Son of man has authority on earth to forgive sins” and exercises this divine power: “Your sins are forgiven.” Further, by virtue of his divine authority he gives this power to men to exercise in his name." This clearly indicates that it is not the individual priest who is forgiving sins and granting absolution... It is the priest acting in the name of Jesus Christ. This is a role that is granted to the priest when Holy Orders are bestowed upon him.

  • Fr. Chuck Bradley
share|improve this answer
1  
You've written a long text about penance, but you haven't clearly answered the question. Can you please edit this to more clearly answer whether Christians have the authority to forgive sin? –  curiousdannii Jul 13 at 22:08

Christians only have the authority to forgive sin directed at themselves, the individual, as someone answered above Jesus says we must forgive those who have sinned against us or else God will not forgive us. When it comes to forgiving sin against others not ourselves only God, Jesus and the person who has been sinned against has the authority to forgive the sin.

I am only answering from the Bible here as I am from a Baptist background.

share|improve this answer

This post does not cite any references or sources. Please help improve this post by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.

2  
This answer needs more support. It needs sources, and citations, if necessary, to support what you are saying. Otherwise, it just looks like your opinion. Please add more to it to make a truly academic answer. Thank you. –  fredsbend Jul 16 at 5:30

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.