Take the 2-minute tour ×
Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Really, this question can also be answered from other similar viewpoints to Wesleyan, such as Methodist or perhaps Lutheran. The closer to Wesleyan, the better.

Anyway, just as the title asks: what is marriage? Is it the legal procedure and contract that binds two people together with the force of law? Does there have to be a ceremony (a wedding)? Do common law marriages count, where the couple acts as though they were legally married? How about other cultural wedding ceremonies, such as hand-fastening?

I did some Googling for "wesleyan common law marriage", and basically the only relevant result I found was this article (from English 205 at a Wesleyan college), which pretty much says that around the time of Shakespeare, common law marriages were looked down on by church people, possibly even considered invalid. 'Course, that was in the late 1500s and the Wesleyan Church started in the mid 1800s, about 250 years later. So I would expect to see that the Wesleyan attitude is different today.

To clarify the ideas I'm attempting to express here, suppose that you have two people, Adam and Belle, that are in common law marriages with Danielle and Charles, respectively. So Adam is "married" to Danielle and Belle is "married" to Charles. Now, if these common law marriages are not valid, then if Adam and Belle have sex, they are not committing adultery. Depending on how you define "extramarital sex", they would then be either having extramarital sex or premarital sex, and the morality of the latter is uncertain.

Aside from the legalities, what about the spiritual side of it? Suppose that two Christian strangers meet spontaneously and get married within the hour, with the legal procedure completely satisfied. (Maybe an hour is pushing it, but in as short of a time as possible.) Suppose that neither are under the influence of drugs or alcohol, so the consent given is valid. Ignoring how this would probably very much not be what God wants, is this marriage as equally valid as a "normal" one? Or does/should a marriage include both a legal process and a spiritual covenant? Or...even...is it possible to be married by spiritual covenant alone?

I ought to note that I am not interested in the issue of homosexuality. This question asks about what defines a marriage between a man and a woman.

share|improve this question
I don't understand. Why do you say "If there is no marriage"? –  curiousdannii Jun 23 at 0:11
@curiousdannii: "extramarital" means "outside of marriage". If a common-law marriage does not count as a marriage, then there cannot be any extramarital sex. Or, depending on your interpretation, the couple would be having extramarital sex all the time. –  El'endia Starman Jun 23 at 1:05
Okay, but I'm not sure of the point of this question... where's the research effort? Did a Wesleyan you know or read say that civil marriages don't count as religious marriages? Did a Wesleyan say that marriage no longer exists? –  curiousdannii Jun 23 at 3:22
@curiousdannii: I updated the question. –  El'endia Starman Jun 23 at 13:25
@curiousdannii: Perhaps. I'm not sure either, but I feel like Protestantism is too broad. Hence why I made the note at the beginning that I would allow Methodist and other similar perspectives. –  El'endia Starman Jun 24 at 2:47

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.