Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I mean a desire that we might place within Plato's theory of The Forms: that is, that you experience longing 'through' an object/idea on Earth (say, a cat, film or landscape) because, in Heaven, there IS a higher, perfected, joyous version of that thing (that the World version is only a very rough version of: to use CS Lewis's analogy, like a pencil drawing before a real landscape).

I do, of course, mean things we deeply, deeply want (not flippant things like drink and drugs (unless your a wine taster, where the first isn't such a meager passion but is an art form)). Does the existence of a desire, to paraphrase (for the millionth time in my life) Lewis, prove that something must exist for us to naturally develop such a need?

share|improve this question
up vote 3 down vote accepted

It is not a necessity, no.

Remember that even the Christian still struggles with sin & rebellion, even after he or she has been justified by the Cross of Christ. This is quite clear in Romans 7:13-25, where we resonate with Paul's daily struggle with his inability to live according to the righteousness to which he's been called. In that text, Paul paints the picture of the "inner self", or what we may also call "how the Father sees us" at war with our flesh, or the life that we've come out of. Paul mentions that the other members of his body (including our mind, passions, etc.) are still in that limbo state between doing the will of God and shedding our former sinful nature.

For the Christian, we are to test our desires, to see if they are of Christ and the Spirit, and then to pursue those which are with everything that we are. In essence, if we follow John 14:15, we'll be safe.

Love Jesus, do whatever you desire.

The catch is this: But in that order (love Jesus first, live it out second). Not every desire results out of loving Jesus.

(That is a paraphrasing of St. Augustine, but fairly accurate in my assessment).

To answer your original question for the person who is not yet a Christian: if the earthly fulfillment of their desire still leaves them longing (a la Plato's Forms in a sense, or more accurately a la Ecclesiastes 3:11), then it is most likely that it is indeed given to them by and for the Trinity.

In summary, it is not a necessity that a desire points to God, but the longing that results from an unfulfilled desire does point us to God. I would also caution against Platonic reasoning, because it's so antithetical to the Gospel. For more reading on that, check out NT Wright's Surprised By Hope. Fantastic explanation on how Plato and Western civilization clash with the Gospel and the Biblical understanding of "forms".

Hope this helps!

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.