The Catholicism and Orthodox churches do not recognize the Eucharist of protestant churches. Why not?
- Anybody can ask a question
- Anybody can answer
- The best answers are voted up and rise to the top
As far as both Catholics and Orthodox are concerned, you need a validly ordained priest to confect the Eucharist.(see e.g. CCC, ¶1411) As far as they are concerned, none of the churches that originate from the Reformation period have what is required for a valid priesthood (i.e. bishops in unbroken tactile succession from the Apostles(see CCC, ¶1576)), so the Eucharist cannot be validly celebrated by these churches.
This may look uncharitable on the surface. In reality, the Catholics and Orthodox could not accept the validity of Protestant Eucharists without significantly altering their own doctrine.
On another related point, it's worth noting that Catholics and Orthodox do not even properly consider the Protestant churches "Churches" in the proper sense: they are referred to technically as "ecclesial communities" precisely because they have not preserved the sacramental priesthood and therefore the Eucharist:
It's clearly because Catholics believe that the bread and wine are the physical Body and Blood of Christ. Protestants do not. So, therefore, it's a fundamentally different ritual in Protestant churches.
The 1896 Papal Bull declaring all Anglican denominations to be "null and void" was after hundreds and hundreds of years of disagreement on the fundamental nature of the eucharist. I am of the opinion, as an Anglican, that it is merely symbolic and demonstrates our devotion to Christ to do exactly as he said to do when we remember him, for thousands of years.
That's why. Personally, I think it's best not to raise the issue with Catholics. It's not a salvation-killer (is there such a thing, ah a topic for another thread) or anything, after all.
In 1896, Pope Leo XIII issued a papal bull Apostolicae Curae declaring all Anglican ordinations to be "absolutely null and utterly void". This is because of they changed the form of ordination rites in such a way as to render them invalid. This means the Anglicans don't have valid orders and therefore they cannot confect the Eucharist. Changes to the rites of ordination did not occur during the Great Western Schism.